Skip to content

Work Intent: Stop the disks query from spinning up array disks (#2018) #2105

Open

Description

@jandrop

Overview

Fix #2018. Any query that goes through DisksService.getDisks() wakes every spun-down array disk: disks, disk(id), assignableDisks and the onboarding Internal Boot step (getAssignableDisks() / getInternalBootDevices()). Even { disks { id } } is enough. Anything that polls the disk list keeps large drives from staying in standby.

The cause is the same one #2090 / #2091 found for temperatures: getDisks() builds its list from diskLayout() in systeminformation, which on Linux runs smartctl -a -j and smartctl -H on every disk without -n standby.

I've been running the approach below as a runtime patch on my own server (Unraid 7.3, mixed array with 16 and 18 TB drives) for a few months. With the disks spun down, { disks { id } } spins up every large drive on stock, and none with the patch. The query also goes from several seconds to under 500 ms.

Technical Approach

  • Replace diskLayout() in getDisks() with a listing from lsblk -d -b -J -O, which only reads kernel metadata. Ideally this builds on getPhysicalDisks() from fix(api): stop temperature metrics from spinning up array disks #2091 once it lands, adding the columns getDisks() needs (vendor, firmware revision, rotational) so there is a single place that lists disks.
  • Map each device to the shape diskLayout() returns today, so parseDisk() stays as it is: device, name (model), vendor, serialNum, firmwareRevision, interfaceType (from tran), size in bytes, and type as HD / SSD / NVMe (from rota and tran, same values diskLayout() returns). lsblk reports vendor: "ATA" for SATA drives, so in that case the vendor is derived from the model string.
  • Get smartStatus from smartctl -n standby -H -j <device>. Exit code 2 means the disk is in standby and was not queried, which maps to UNKNOWN.
  • Keep blockDevices() for partitions.
  • Tests: unit tests for the lsblk mapping (size in bytes, drive type, vendor fallback, filtering out loop/ram devices) and for the smartctl status mapping, plus a test that getDisks() no longer calls diskLayout().

Out of scope: the geometry fields on Disk (bytesPerSector, totalSectors, etc.) are non-nullable but diskLayout() already returns null for them on Linux, so selecting them errors today. This change would leave them as they are; happy to look at that separately.

Scope

  • API
  • Plugin
  • Web UI
  • Build/Deploy Process
  • Documentation

Timeline & Impact

  • Estimated time needed: a few days, since the logic already runs as a patch and mostly needs porting and tests. I'd start after fix(api): stop temperature metrics from spinning up array disks #2091 is merged to avoid conflicts in disks.service.ts.
  • Potential impacts: smartStatus becomes UNKNOWN for disks in standby instead of waking them to read it. No schema changes.

Pre-submission Checklist

  • I have searched for similar work/issues
  • I understand this needs approval before starting
  • I am willing to make adjustments based on feedback

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions