Skip to content

[Feature]: Pin Alarm element permanently next to the Clock in Compact Island #1829

Closed

Description

@DerKney

Problem Statement

Currently, the Alarm element is treated as a dynamic priority slot inside the Compact Island. Depending on active media playback, weather, or notification states, the alarm shifts around or gets pushed to the opposite side of the camera cutout (e.g., landing to the right of the camera while the Clock stays on the left).

When using Essentials Island with the native Android status bar hidden, the Island serves as the primary glanceable status bar. Having the next alarm jump between positions depending on what else is active makes quick checks unreliable and breaks visual muscle memory.

Proposed Solution

Allow the Alarm element to be pinned permanently right next to the Clock (left of the camera cutout) as a static anchor, keeping core time-related info grouped together in a predictable order:

[Battery (if enabled)] -> [Clock] -> [Alarm] -> [Camera Cutout] -> [Dynamic Items]

Implementation Suggestion:

  • Assign CompactPlacement.Pinned to the Alarm item/provider (matching Clock and Battery) instead of CompactPlacement.Dynamic.
  • Enforce a deterministic sub-order for pinned left-side cells in CompactLayoutEngine so the Alarm cell always renders immediately after the Clock cell with standard spacing.
  • Include the pinned Alarm width in the static left-side anchor offset so IslandBalancing keeps the pill symmetrically centered around the camera cutout.
  • Optionally expose this as a toggle ("Pin Alarm next to Clock") in the Island layout settings if keeping the dynamic behavior as default is preferred.

Alternatives Considered

  1. Relying on priority sorting: Even with higher priority, dynamic items still shift sides or rearrange whenever higher-priority live activities (like media playback or timers) start or stop.
  2. Keeping the native Android status bar visible: Defeats one of Essentials Island's best features (full status bar replacement).

Affected Areas

Dynamic Island (CompactLayoutEngine, Alarm provider/item placement, Island Settings UI)

Priority

Medium - Would improve my experience

Contribution

  • I would be willing to implement this feature once it is approved and assigned to me

Additional Context

Users who completely hide the system status bar rely on the left side of the camera cutout for consistent system/time telemetry. Grouping Clock + Alarm together mirrors how dedicated status bars organize time and schedule info, leaving the right side clean for dynamic live activities.

Activity

  1. sameerasw commented on Nov 19, 2026

    @sameerasw
    Owner

    Increase the priority and then enable the persistent ordering option in the next update.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

enhancementNew feature or requestneeds-triageAwaiting maintainer review

Projects

Milestone

No milestone

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions