Repository navigation
Some RSI calculations are missing on the 1 minute timeframe #41
Description
Describe the bug
When running ta.rsi(close, 14) on a 1-minute timeframe dataset of size 1440, only 1434 RSI values are produced.
However, the correct number of results appears when using a 5-minute timeframe dataset.
To Reproduce
Steps to reproduce the behavior:
- Download 1m timeframe datasets.
pyne data download ccxt --symbol "BITGET:BTC/USDT:USDT" --timeframe 1 --from "1" - Create a simple Pyne strategy
"""
@pyne
This code was compiled by PyneComp — the Pine Script to Python compiler.
Accessible via PyneSys: https://pynesys.io
Run with open-source PyneCore: https://pynecore.org
"""
from pynecore import Series
from pynecore.lib import (
close, script, ta, log
)
@script.strategy("my strategy", overlay=True, initial_capital=10000)
def main():
rsi: Series[float] = ta.rsi(close, 14)
log.info("rsi: {0}", rsi)-
Run the strategy
pyne run test ccxt_BITGET_BTC_USDT_USDT_1.ohlcv -
Observe the bar index
The final bar index is much lower than the number of rows in the OHLCV file.
Expected behavior
RSI values should be generated for every bar in the dataset.
Screenshots
- OHLCV file size
pyne runcommand result
- Missing calculations
e.g., 2025-11-14 17:18:00+0000
Environment:
- OS: macOS
- Version: (e.g. Ubuntu 22.04, Windows 11)
- Python version: 3.11, 3.12, 3.13
- How you ran the script: pyne run
Additional context
I tested this issue using the latest pynecore commit.
Activity
wallneradam commentedon Nov 26, 2025
Thank you for taking the time to report this issue and for providing such detailed reproduction steps! This is really helpful.
After investigation, this is actually expected behavior, not a bug. Here's what's happening:
The Cause: Gaps in the Data
The Bitget API doesn't return data for every minute - there are periods with no trading activity. When we downloaded the same data you used, we found:
The gap timestamps (no trading activity from Bitget):
How PyneCore Handles This
volume=-1(a flat candle with previous close price)skip_gaps=True)Why This Is Correct
Calculating RSI (or any indicator) on a "fake" bar with no real price movement would produce misleading results. The 1434 RSI values you're seeing represent all the bars where actual trading occurred.
How to Verify
You can check for gaps in your OHLCV file:
Note: We're converting this issue to a Discussion, as we found it valuable for other users who might encounter the same situation. Thanks again for bringing this up!