diff --git a/astro_data/corrections/README.md b/astro_data/corrections/README.md index 9f9f0b3c8..bb2e92b67 100644 --- a/astro_data/corrections/README.md +++ b/astro_data/corrections/README.md @@ -77,10 +77,15 @@ If the field is empty in the database, write `was. = ""`. | `mag` | a number, or a list for a variable's range | `11.4`, `[4.86, 7.32]` | | `description` | text; a multi-line string is fine | `"""…"""` | +- `size` and `mag` can be cleared with `""`, for a sky object left holding + another object's value that no source replaces: the sky object a split + (`own_object`) copies from its old one, or the one a moved identification + leaves behind. - `ra` and `dec` take two or three parts, and only the last may have decimals. A bare number is refused, because it could be hours or degrees. - `size` is read by the loaders' own `parse_arcmin_size`, and must parse - whole. It corrects the extents. The position angle stays as it was. + whole, into finite, positive extents: `"nan"`, `"inf"`, `"0"` and `"-5"` + are refused. It corrects the extents. The position angle stays as it was. - Correcting `ra` or `dec` recomputes the constellation from the new position, as a loader would. To overrule that, for a boundary case like NGC 1404, correct `const` too. @@ -112,6 +117,10 @@ These correct which sky object a designator belongs to. whole sky object merges in, names and all, and is deleted. The target's values stand and the merged object's are dropped, so correct anything worth keeping in the same table. +- **`guard = false`**, with a `same_as` only: skip the match guard for an + identification the sources confirm although the listing's own position + or type is wrong (Collinder's Dec slip for Col 208 = IC 2488). Say in + `why` what is wrong with the listing. See the checks below. - **`own_object = true`**: this designator is a sky object of its own. Its listing moves to a new sky object that starts as a copy of the old one. Correct its fields in the same table, with `was` stating the copied @@ -155,6 +164,14 @@ The import fails, naming the file and the designator, when: own sky object; - a `same_as` points at a designator that has its own `same_as` (point it at the final sky object instead); +- a `same_as` fails the loaders' match guard: the listing's own type and + position, those of the sky object it leaves, must be compatible with the + sky object it joins, as corrected, and lie within 30′ of it or within its + major axis. If the identification is right and the listing's position or + type is wrong, say so in `why` and add `guard = false`. A `guard = false` + on a `same_as` the guard accepts is redundant, and fails too. An + `own_object` has no such check: its new sky object starts at the old + position, and any field it corrects carries its own `was`; - a split or join leaves its old sky object still carrying another catalog's name that the loaders' lookup resolves to the designator: a designation `parse_designation` reads as it ("Cr 42" for Col 42, diff --git a/astro_data/corrections/arp.toml b/astro_data/corrections/arp.toml new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d99f9c3d8 --- /dev/null +++ b/astro_data/corrections/arp.toml @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +# Corrections to the Arp Atlas of Peculiar Galaxies (arp/). +# See README.md in this directory for the format. +# was values from a build of 4da2a0a2b. + +["Arp 65"] +why = "arp.sqlite names Arp 65 'NGC 0091', but NGC 91 is a star 1.9' south, which the match guard rejects. Arp 65 is NGC 90 (with NGC 93), and its position is NGC 90's." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%2090", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=Arp%2065", +] +same_as = "NGC 90" diff --git a/astro_data/corrections/caldwell.toml b/astro_data/corrections/caldwell.toml new file mode 100644 index 000000000..171fe5023 --- /dev/null +++ b/astro_data/corrections/caldwell.toml @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +# Corrections to the Caldwell catalog (caldwell.dat). +# See README.md in this directory for the format. +# was values from a build of 4da2a0a2b. + +["C 41"] +why = "caldwell.dat gives no designation for C 41, the Hyades ('none'), so no loader can join it to Collinder's Col 50 = Mel 25 at the same position: two objects one pixel apart." +sources = [ + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/addendum.csv", + "https://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/VizieR-3?-source=J/A%2BA/673/A114/clusters", +] +same_as = "Col 50" diff --git a/astro_data/corrections/collinder.toml b/astro_data/corrections/collinder.toml new file mode 100644 index 000000000..31ae4d44b --- /dev/null +++ b/astro_data/corrections/collinder.toml @@ -0,0 +1,62 @@ +# Corrections to the Collinder catalog (collinder.txt, collinder2.txt). +# See README.md in this directory for the format. +# was values from a build of 4da2a0a2b. + +["Lyn 855"] +why = "collinder.txt places Collinder 401 at -00 20, 39' from SIMBAD's +00 19 00, so Lyngå's Lyn 855, which names it 'Collinder 401' and lies at +00 20, could not join it. One cluster." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=Cl%20Collinder%20401"] +same_as = "Col 401" + +["Col 401"] +why = "collinder.txt has -00 20; SIMBAD has Collinder 401 at 19 38 24.0 +00 19 00, and Lyngå (Lyn 855, which names it 'Collinder 401') at +00 20, whose B1950 +00 13 precesses to that." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=Cl%20Collinder%20401"] +dec = "+00 19 00" +was.dec = "-00 20 00.0" + +["Lyn 829"] +why = "collinder.txt places Collinder 394 45.8' too far south (-20 59 28; SIMBAD -20 13 44), so Lyngå's Lyn 829, which names it 'Collinder 394', could not join it. One cluster." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=Cl%20Collinder%20394"] +same_as = "Col 394" + +["Col 394"] +why = "collinder.txt has -20 59 28, 45.8' south of SIMBAD's 18 52 22.1 -20 13 44 (Tarricq et al. 2021); its RA is right." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=Cl%20Collinder%20394"] +dec = "-20 13 44" +was.dec = "-20 59 28.0" + +["Col 8"] +why = "Collinder gives IC 1590 30'x25', which now fills the sky object's missing size. Corwin: 6'x4', the cluster involved in NGC 281; Dias 4'." +sources = [ + "Corwin, IC notes (IC 1590)", + "Dias+ 2002", + "Kharchenko+ 2013 MWSC", +] +size = "6'x4'" +was.size = "30'x25'" + +["Col 417"] +why = "Collinder's 8.1 for Col 417 = NGC 6885 = C 37 fills the cluster's missing magnitude, since Collinder loads before Caldwell. The cluster is about 5.7-5.9 (caldwell.dat 5.9)." +sources = [ + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/ngconly.txt", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%206885", + "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caldwell_catalogue", +] +mag = 5.9 +was.mag = 8.1 + +["NGC 457"] +why = "collinder2.txt gives NGC 457 the one name 'Owl or E.T. Cluster', which is two names in one string; the sky object already carries 'The Owl Cluster' (TAAS)." +sources = ["https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NGC_457"] +names.remove = ["Owl or E.T. Cluster"] + +["IC 2602"] +why = "collinder2.txt's 'Theta Carinae Cluster, Southern Pleiades' is two names in one string; the sky object already carries 'Southern Pleiades'." +sources = ["https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IC_2602"] +names.remove = ["Theta Carinae Cluster, Southern Pleiades"] + +["Col 208"] +why = "collinder.txt names Collinder 208 'IC 2488' and gives IC 2488's magnitude (7.4) and size (18'), but a Dec of -57 40, 43' south of IC 2488 (SIMBAD 09 27 25.7 -57 00 14), so the match guard rejects the join: a Dec slip in Collinder." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=IC%202488"] +same_as = "IC 2488" +guard = false diff --git a/astro_data/corrections/lynga.toml b/astro_data/corrections/lynga.toml new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f5ddde0d4 --- /dev/null +++ b/astro_data/corrections/lynga.toml @@ -0,0 +1,23 @@ +# Corrections to Lyngå's Catalogue of Open Cluster Data (lynga/). +# See README.md in this directory for the format. +# was values from a build of 4da2a0a2b. + +["Lyn 919"] +why = "Lyngå names this cluster 'NGC 6996', but its position, 20 56.5 +44 37, is NGC 6997's (Steinicke +44 39); NGC 6996 is 51' north. One cluster." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%206997", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%206996", +] +same_as = "NGC 6997" + +["Lyn 866"] +why = "Lyngå names this cluster NGC 6846 and gives its RA, size and magnitude (14.2), but a declination of +30 21, two degrees south of NGC 6846's +32 20 56 (SIMBAD): a slip in Lyngå." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%206846"] +same_as = "NGC 6846" +guard = false + +["Lyn 639"] +why = "Lyngå's 'Collinder 285', the Ursa Major Moving Group, at 14 40.9 +69 34 (SIMBAD C 1440+697 = Cl Collinder 285 follows it), and Collinder's own Col 285 at 12 03 +58 (the Big Dipper's core) are one group with two centres, 20 degrees apart (Rich's decision, #680)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=C%201440%2B697"] +same_as = "Col 285" +guard = false diff --git a/astro_data/corrections/ngc2000_names.toml b/astro_data/corrections/ngc2000_names.toml new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5be965dc3 --- /dev/null +++ b/astro_data/corrections/ngc2000_names.toml @@ -0,0 +1,51 @@ +# Corrections to NGC 2000.0's names file (ngc_ic_m/ngc2000/names.dat; Sinnott 1988, CDS VII/118). +# See README.md in this directory for the format. +# was values from a build of 4da2a0a2b. + +["M 82"] +why = "NGC 2000.0's names.dat gives 'Bode's nebulae', the name of the M 81/M 82 pair, to M 82 alone. M 82 is the Cigar Galaxy, which messier_names.dat already puts first." +sources = [ + "https://cdsarc.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/cat/VII/118", + "http://www.messier.seds.org/m/m082.html", + "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Messier_objects", +] +names.remove = ["Bode's Nebulae"] + +["IC 434"] +why = "NGC 2000.0's names.dat puts 'Horsehead nebula' on IC 434; its own note says 'Dark nebula in IC 434'. The Horsehead is Barnard 33." +sources = [ + "https://cdsarc.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/cat/VII/118", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=Barnard%2033", + "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IC_434", + "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horsehead_Nebula", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +names.remove = ["Horsehead Nebula"] + +["B 33"] +why = "The other half of names.dat's misplaced 'Horsehead nebula': the dark nebula in IC 434 is Barnard 33." +sources = [ + "https://cdsarc.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/cat/VII/118", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=Barnard%2033", + "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horsehead_Nebula", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +names.preferred = "Horsehead Nebula" + +["NGC 5195"] +why = "NGC 2000.0's names.dat gives 'M51' and 'Whirlpool galaxy' to NGC 5195 as well as to NGC 5194. M 51 is NGC 5194; NGC 5195 is its companion." +sources = [ + "https://cdsarc.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/cat/VII/118", + "http://www.messier.seds.org/m/m051.html", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=61%20Cet", +] +names.remove = ["M51", "Whirlpool Galaxy"] + +["NGC 2261"] +why = "NGC 2000.0's names.dat truncates the name to 'Hubble's variable neb'. NGC 2261 already carries the full 'Hubble's Variable Nebula' from the Caldwell list." +sources = [ + "https://cdsarc.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/cat/VII/118", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%202261", + "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NGC_2261", +] +names.remove = ["Hubble's Variable Neb"] diff --git a/astro_data/corrections/rasc_doubles.toml b/astro_data/corrections/rasc_doubles.toml new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ef715ff72 --- /dev/null +++ b/astro_data/corrections/rasc_doubles.toml @@ -0,0 +1,8 @@ +# Corrections to the RASC Observer's Handbook double stars (RASC_DoubleStars). +# See README.md in this directory for the format. +# was values from a build of 4da2a0a2b. + +["RDS 69"] +why = "The row's catalog number names no Hipparcos star, so the designation check vetoes the match, though WDS confirms the star. Evidence: WDS STF2486 lies 0.00' from HIP 94336; V 5.8 fits HIP 94336 5.85, no other star within 3' does." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2094336"] +hip = 94336 diff --git a/astro_data/corrections/sac_multistars.toml b/astro_data/corrections/sac_multistars.toml new file mode 100644 index 000000000..716bb62ed --- /dev/null +++ b/astro_data/corrections/sac_multistars.toml @@ -0,0 +1,373 @@ +# Corrections to the Saguaro Astronomy Club Double Stars list, version 4.0 (SAC_Multistars_Ver40). +# See README.md in this directory for the format. +# was values from a build of 4da2a0a2b. + +["SaM 1414"] +why = "A SAC continuation row gives no V, so the cross-match cannot gate it, and the system's first row does not identify it. Evidence: 30 Ori is HIP 25473." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2025473"] +hip = 25473 + +["SaM 1862"] +why = "A SAC continuation row gives no V, so the cross-match cannot gate it, and the system's first row does not identify it. Evidence: WDS BUP203 lies 0.15' from HIP 98909." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2098909"] +hip = 98909 + +["SaM 892"] +why = "SAC's position or magnitude is off, so the cross-match finds no star, or the wrong component. Evidence: 38 Gem is HIP 33202; source's V is the error (V 7.4 vs HIP 33202 4.73)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2033202"] +hip = 33202 + +["SaM 1084"] +why = "SAC's position or magnitude is off, so the cross-match finds no star, or the wrong component. Evidence: WDS STF1364 lies 0.00' from HIP 46781; source's V is the error (V 7.5 vs HIP 46781 8.56)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2046781"] +hip = 46781 + +["SaM 1418"] +why = "SAC's position or magnitude is off, so the cross-match finds no star, or the wrong component. Evidence: 31 Ori is HIP 25737; source's V is the error (V 6 vs HIP 25737 4.71)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2025737"] +hip = 25737 + +["SaM 1445"] +why = "SAC's position or magnitude is off, so the cross-match finds no star, or the wrong component. Evidence: 42 Ori is HIP 26237." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2026237"] +hip = 26237 + +["SaM 649"] +why = "SAC's row lies 3-6' from its star, outside the cross-match's 3' radius for a rounded position. Evidence: V 6.3 fits HIP 80247 6.41, no other star within 3' does." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2080247"] +hip = 80247 + +["SaM 958"] +why = "SAC's row lies 3-6' from its star, outside the cross-match's 3' radius for a rounded position. Evidence: Alpha Her is HIP 84345." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2084345"] +hip = 84345 + +["SaM 975"] +why = "SAC's row lies 3-6' from its star, outside the cross-match's 3' radius for a rounded position. Evidence: 90 Her is HIP 87563; V 5.2 fits HIP 87563 5.17, no other star within 3' does." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2087563"] +hip = 87563 + +["SaM 992"] +why = "SAC's row lies 3-6' from its star, outside the cross-match's 3' radius for a rounded position. Evidence: 110 Her is HIP 92043; V 4.2 fits HIP 92043 4.19, no other star within 3' does." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2092043"] +hip = 92043 + +["SaM 993"] +why = "SAC's row lies 3-6' from its star, outside the cross-match's 3' radius for a rounded position. Evidence: 110 Her is HIP 92043; V 4.2 fits HIP 92043 4.19, no other star within 3' does." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2092043"] +hip = 92043 + +["SaM 1136"] +why = "SAC's row lies 3-6' from its star, outside the cross-match's 3' radius for a rounded position. Evidence: Iota Lep is HIP 24244; V 4.2 fits HIP 24244 4.45, no other star within 3' does." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2024244"] +hip = 24244 + +["SaM 1432"] +why = "SAC's row lies 3-6' from its star, outside the cross-match's 3' radius for a rounded position. Evidence: Lambda Ori is HIP 26207." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2026207"] +hip = 26207 + +["SaM 1433"] +why = "SAC's row lies 3-6' from its star, outside the cross-match's 3' radius for a rounded position. Evidence: Lambda Ori is HIP 26207." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2026207"] +hip = 26207 + +["SaM 1477"] +why = "SAC's row lies 3-6' from its star, outside the cross-match's 3' radius for a rounded position. Evidence: Xi Pav is HIP 90098; V 4.3 fits HIP 90098 4.35, no other star within 3' does." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2090098"] +hip = 90098 + +["SaM 1814"] +why = "SAC's row lies 3-6' from its star, outside the cross-match's 3' radius for a rounded position. Evidence: Delta Ser is HIP 76276; V 4.2 fits HIP 76276 3.80, no other star within 3' does." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2076276"] +hip = 76276 + +["SaM 2082"] +why = "SAC's row lies 3-6' from its star, outside the cross-match's 3' radius for a rounded position. Evidence: Beta Vir is HIP 57757; Zavijava is HIP 57757; V 3.8 fits HIP 57757 3.59, no other star within 3' does." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2057757"] +hip = 57757 + +["SaM 2083"] +why = "SAC's row lies 3-6' from its star, outside the cross-match's 3' radius for a rounded position. Evidence: Beta Vir is HIP 57757; Zavijava is HIP 57757; V 3.8 fits HIP 57757 3.59, no other star within 3' does." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2057757"] +hip = 57757 + +["SaM 43"] +why = "Both components of the pair have a Hipparcos entry, so the cross-match finds two stars and makes no match; this is the component the evidence names. Evidence: [6.5, 7] fits HIP 10176 (6.09) and HIP 10180 (6.82)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2010176"] +hip = 10176 + +["SaM 134"] +why = "Both components of the pair have a Hipparcos entry, so the cross-match finds two stars and makes no match; this is the component the evidence names. Evidence: 94 Aqr is HIP 115126." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%20115126"] +hip = 115126 + +["SaM 144"] +why = "Both components of the pair have a Hipparcos entry, so the cross-match finds two stars and makes no match; this is the component the evidence names. Evidence: [6.6, 7.4] fits HIP 12189 (6.48) and HIP 12184 (7.10)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2012189"] +hip = 12189 + +["SaM 211"] +why = "Both components of the pair have a Hipparcos entry, so the cross-match finds two stars and makes no match; this is the component the evidence names. Evidence: [7, 7.5] fits HIP 73366 (6.84) and HIP 73368 (7.64)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2073366"] +hip = 73366 + +["SaM 259"] +why = "Both components of the pair have a Hipparcos entry, so the cross-match finds two stars and makes no match; this is the component the evidence names. Evidence: WDS STF1122 lies 0.25' from HIP 37882." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2037882"] +hip = 37882 + +["SaM 272"] +why = "Both components of the pair have a Hipparcos entry, so the cross-match finds two stars and makes no match; this is the component the evidence names. Evidence: [6, 6.8] fits HIP 101123 (5.94) and HIP 101120 (6.74)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%20101123"] +hip = 101123 + +["SaM 569"] +why = "Both components of the pair have a Hipparcos entry, so the cross-match finds two stars and makes no match; this is the component the evidence names. Evidence: WDS STF1219 lies 0.21' from HIP 41090." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2041090"] +hip = 41090 + +["SaM 628"] +why = "Both components of the pair have a Hipparcos entry, so the cross-match finds two stars and makes no match; this is the component the evidence names. Evidence: [5.9, 6.6] fits HIP 90968 (5.67) and HIP 90969 (6.31)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2090968"] +hip = 90968 + +["SaM 742"] +why = "Both components of the pair have a Hipparcos entry, so the cross-match finds two stars and makes no match; this is the component the evidence names. Evidence: [5.2, 6] fits HIP 104214 (5.20) and HIP 104217 (6.05)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%20104214"] +hip = 104214 + +["SaM 767"] +why = "Both components of the pair have a Hipparcos entry, so the cross-match finds two stars and makes no match; this is the component the evidence names. Evidence: [4.5, 5.5] fits HIP 102532 (4.27) and HIP 102531 (5.15)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%20102532"] +hip = 102532 + +["SaM 794"] +why = "Both components of the pair have a Hipparcos entry, so the cross-match finds two stars and makes no match; this is the component the evidence names. Evidence: [4.9, 6.1] fits HIP 86614 (4.57) and HIP 86620 (5.81)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2086614"] +hip = 86614 + +["SaM 797"] +why = "Both components of the pair have a Hipparcos entry, so the cross-match finds two stars and makes no match; this is the component the evidence names. Evidence: [5.7, 6.1] fits HIP 88136 (5.74) and HIP 88127 (6.11)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2088136"] +hip = 88136 + +["SaM 886"] +why = "Both components of the pair have a Hipparcos entry, so the cross-match finds two stars and makes no match; this is the component the evidence names. Evidence: 20 Gem is HIP 31158; [6.3, 6.9] fits HIP 31158 (6.26) and HIP 31156 (6.91)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2031158"] +hip = 31158 + +["SaM 928"] +why = "Both components of the pair have a Hipparcos entry, so the cross-match finds two stars and makes no match; this is the component the evidence names. Evidence: SAC's [5.3, 6.5] fits HIP 79043 (5.00) and HIP 79045 (6.25)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2079043"] +hip = 79043 + +["SaM 1068"] +why = "Both components of the pair have a Hipparcos entry, so the cross-match finds two stars and makes no match; this is the component the evidence names. Evidence: [5.7, 6.5] fits HIP 111546 (5.73) and HIP 111544 (6.60)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%20111546"] +hip = 111546 + +["SaM 1437"] +why = "Both components of the pair have a Hipparcos entry, so the cross-match finds two stars and makes no match; this is the component the evidence names. Evidence: Theta2 Ori is HIP 26235." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2026235"] +hip = 26235 + +["SaM 1462"] +why = "Both components of the pair have a Hipparcos entry, so the cross-match finds two stars and makes no match; this is the component the evidence names. Evidence: 59 Ori is HIP 28271." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2028271"] +hip = 28271 + +["SaM 1611"] +why = "Both components of the pair have a Hipparcos entry, so the cross-match finds two stars and makes no match; this is the component the evidence names. Evidence: 57 Per is HIP 21242." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2021242"] +hip = 21242 + +["SaM 1657"] +why = "Both components of the pair have a Hipparcos entry, so the cross-match finds two stars and makes no match; this is the component the evidence names. Evidence: [5.6, 6.5] fits HIP 5737 (5.21) and HIP 5743 (6.44)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%205737"] +hip = 5737 + +["SaM 1672"] +why = "Both components of the pair have a Hipparcos entry, so the cross-match finds two stars and makes no match; this is the component the evidence names. Evidence: [7.8, 8.3] fits HIP 116035 (7.76) and HIP 116036 (8.33)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%20116035"] +hip = 116035 + +["SaM 1710"] +why = "Both components of the pair have a Hipparcos entry, so the cross-match finds two stars and makes no match; this is the component the evidence names. Evidence: SAC's [6.1, 6.8] fits HIP 37843 (6.06) and HIP 37842 (7.03)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2037843"] +hip = 37843 + +["SaM 1844"] +why = "Both components of the pair have a Hipparcos entry, so the cross-match finds two stars and makes no match; this is the component the evidence names. Evidence: Alya is HIP 92946." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2092946"] +hip = 92946 + +["SaM 1922"] +why = "Both components of the pair have a Hipparcos entry, so the cross-match finds two stars and makes no match; this is the component the evidence names. Evidence: SAC's [5.6, 6.4] fits HIP 17579 (5.76) and HIP 17588 (6.43)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2017579"] +hip = 17579 + +["SaM 1211"] +why = "The source's position is too far off for the star cross-match to find the star. Evidence: Xi Lup is HIP 78105; V 5.3 fits HIP 78105 5.14, no other star within 3' does." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2078105"] +hip = 78105 + +["SaM 1297"] +why = "The source's position is too far off for the star cross-match to find the star. Evidence: Alpha Mic is HIP 102831; V 5 fits HIP 102831 4.89, no other star within 3' does." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%20102831"] +hip = 102831 + +["SaM 465"] +why = "A variable whose catalog magnitude is not Hipparcos's V, so the cross-match's V gate turns its star away. Evidence: Omicron Cet is HIP 10826; Mira is HIP 10826." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2010826"] +hip = 10826 + +["SaM 307"] +why = "SAC names this row 'Beta1 Cas' and 'Caph', but at 00 52.8 +56 38 it is BU 1 (HD 5005, the Trapezium of NGC 281). Caph is beta Cas, at 00 09 +59 09." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HD%205005", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=bet%20Cas", + "https://www.pas.rochester.edu/~emamajek/WGSN/IAU-CSN.txt", +] +names.remove = ["Beta1 Cas", "Caph"] + +["SaM 1709"] +why = "SAC names this row 'Kappa Pup' and 'Markeb', but it is k Pup (Roman k1/k2 Pup). Markeb is kappa Vel (IAU WGSN)." +sources = [ + "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/K_Puppis", + "https://www.pas.rochester.edu/~emamajek/WGSN/IAU-CSN.txt", +] +names.remove = ["Kappa Pup", "Markeb"] +names.add = ["k Pup"] + +["SaM 1348"] +why = "SAC names this row 'Nu Oph', but at 16 27.8 -08 22 it is upsilon Oph (HIP 80628): a nu/upsilon confusion." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=ups%20Oph"] +names.remove = ["Nu Oph"] +names.add = ["Upsilon Oph"] + +["SaM 2003"] +why = "SAC names this row 'Omicron2 UMa' and 'Muscida', but at 09 10.4 +67 08 it is sigma2 UMa (STF 1306): a sigma/omicron confusion. Muscida is omicron UMa, at 08 30 +60 43." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=sig02%20UMa", + "https://www.pas.rochester.edu/~emamajek/WGSN/IAU-CSN.txt", +] +names.remove = ["Omicron2 UMa", "Muscida"] +names.add = ["Sigma2 UMa"] + +["SaM 853"] +why = "omicron2 Eri is right, but its name is Keid, which the sky object already carries from RASC; Beid is omicron1 Eri (IAU WGSN)." +sources = ["https://www.pas.rochester.edu/~emamajek/WGSN/IAU-CSN.txt"] +names.remove = ["Beid"] + +["SaM 860"] +why = "SAC names this row '65 Eri', but STF 590 at 04 46 -08 48 is 55 Eri." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=55%20Eri"] +names.remove = ["65 Eri"] +names.add = ["55 Eri"] + +["SaM 835"] +why = "SAC names this row 'Rho Eri' as well as 'p Eri', but at 01 39.8 -56 12 it is p Eri (DUN 5): Roman p read as Greek rho." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=p%20Eri"] +names.remove = ["Rho Eri"] + +["SaM 1165"] +why = "SAC names this row '33 Lib', but H N 28 at 14 57.5 -21 25 is Gliese 570 (KX Lib), '33 G. Librae', a Gould number. Flamsteed's 33 Lib is HIP 75848." +sources = [ + "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gliese_570", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=Gliese%20570", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=GJ%20570", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=33%20Lib", +] +names.remove = ["33 Lib"] +names.add = ["Gliese 570"] + +["SaM 1771"] +why = "SAC names nu Sco 'Lesath' (AB row) and 'Laseth' (AC and CD rows). nu Sco is Jabbah (IAU WGSN), which the WGSN supplementary source gives it as its preferred name; Lesath is upsilon Sco, and 'Laseth' misspells it." +sources = [ + "https://www.pas.rochester.edu/~emamajek/WGSN/IAU-CSN.txt", + "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nu_Scorpii", +] +names.remove = ["Lesath", "Laseth"] + +["SaM 1440"] +why = "SAC's 'Hatsya' misspells iota Ori's IAU name, Hatysa, which the WGSN supplementary source adds." +sources = [ + "https://www.pas.rochester.edu/~emamajek/WGSN/IAU-CSN.txt", + "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iota_Orionis", +] +names.remove = ["Hatsya"] + +["SaM 587"] +why = "SAC's 'Ascellus Australis' misspells delta Cnc's IAU name, Asellus Australis, which the WGSN supplementary source adds." +sources = ["https://www.pas.rochester.edu/~emamajek/WGSN/IAU-CSN.txt"] +names.remove = ["Ascellus Australis"] + +["SaM 1252"] +why = "SAC names this row 'Zeta2 Lyr', but its 4.3/5.9 at 43.7\" is the zeta1-zeta2 Lyr pair with zeta1 (V 4.36) as primary." +sources = [ + "Bright Star Catalogue V/50 via VizieR HR 7056 zeta1 Lyr 4.36, HR 7057 zeta2 Lyr 5.73", + "WDS, wds_precise.txt as shipped in PiFinder astro_data/WDS (GSU/USNO, 2025-09) 18448+3736 STFA 38", +] +names.remove = ["Zeta2 Lyr"] +names.add = ["Zeta1 Lyr"] + +["SaM 457"] +why = "SAC's 'Burnham pm' on 38 Cet is a note (a Burnham proper-motion pair, BUP 18), not a name." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=38%20Cet"] +names.remove = ["Burnham pm"] + +["SaM 1667"] +why = "SAC's 'Al Rischa (Alrescha)' holds two spellings in one string; the IAU name is Alrescha, which the WGSN supplementary source adds." +sources = ["https://www.pas.rochester.edu/~emamajek/WGSN/IAU-CSN.txt"] +names.remove = ["Al Rischa (Alrescha)"] + +["SaM 1521"] +why = "SAC names xi Peg 'Menkib', which is xi Per's name (IAU WGSN). xi Peg's own IAU name, Tugongli (2026), is the WGSN supplementary source's to add." +sources = ["https://www.pas.rochester.edu/~emamajek/WGSN/IAU-CSN.txt"] +names.remove = ["Menkib"] + +["SaM 1633"] +why = "SAC lists Fomalhaut as a double, so the D* rule types it D*. Its 14 mag companion at 30\" is See's lambda 478, which Burnham showed is a field star, and WDS has dropped it (Mamajek et al. 2013)." +sources = [ + "WDS, wds_precise.txt as shipped in PiFinder astro_data/WDS (GSU/USNO, 2025-09): 22577-2937 KAL 1, SHY 106, MAM 1 only", + "https://arxiv.org/pdf/1310.0764 (Mamajek et al. 2013, Fomalhaut C, section on See 1898)", + "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fomalhaut", +] +obj_type = "*" +was.obj_type = "D*" + +["SaM 1745"] +why = "SAC lists zeta Scl as a double, so the D* rule types it D*. Its only pair, B 631, is flagged X (dubious) in WDS." +sources = [ + "WDS, wds_precise.txt as shipped in PiFinder astro_data/WDS (GSU/USNO, 2025-09): 00023-2943 B 631 [NX]", + "SIMBAD (sim-tap, V and otype) (* zet Scl, SB*)", +] +obj_type = "*" +was.obj_type = "D*" + +["SaM 1241"] +why = "SAC lists Vega AB, so the D* rule types Vega D*. Its WDS companions are all field stars: H 5 39 AB 9.5 at 85\" (U, non-physical), STFB 9 AC 11.0 at 79\" and AE 9.5 at 83\" (S), and faint MET 11 stars, so to an observer it is a single star (the audit: * equally acceptable; planned in #683)." +sources = [ + "WDS, wds_precise.txt as shipped in PiFinder astro_data/WDS (GSU/USNO, 2025-09)", + "Hipparcos I/239 hip_main.dat (PiFinder astro_data), CCDM fields H55-H62", + "Bright Star Catalogue V/50 via VizieR", +] +obj_type = "*" +was.obj_type = "D*" + +["SaM 693"] +why = "SAC's STF 2576 row (8.0/8.0 at 19 46.0 +33 36) lies about 5' from its star, outside the cross-match's 3' radius, and no WDS row names it. STF 2576 AB is HD 186858 = HIP 97222 (V 7.66, K5V+K5V), WDS 19464+3344 FG at 19 45 33.5 +33 36 07." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HD%20186858", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2097222", +] +hip = 97222 + +["SaM 1773"] +why = "SAC names nu Sco 'Lesath' (AB row) and 'Laseth' (AC and CD rows). nu Sco is Jabbah (IAU WGSN), which the WGSN supplementary source gives it as its preferred name; Lesath is upsilon Sco, and 'Laseth' misspells it." +sources = [ + "https://www.pas.rochester.edu/~emamajek/WGSN/IAU-CSN.txt", + "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nu_Scorpii", +] +names.remove = ["Laseth"] diff --git a/astro_data/corrections/sac_redstars.toml b/astro_data/corrections/sac_redstars.toml new file mode 100644 index 000000000..24b25f6f7 --- /dev/null +++ b/astro_data/corrections/sac_redstars.toml @@ -0,0 +1,51 @@ +# Corrections to the Saguaro Astronomy Club Red Stars list, version 2.0 (SAC_RedStars_Ver20). +# See README.md in this directory for the format. +# was values from a build of 4da2a0a2b. + +["SaR 110"] +why = "SAC's position or magnitude is off, so the cross-match finds no star, or the wrong component. Evidence: Gamma Cru is HIP 61084; source's V is the error (V 3.6 vs HIP 61084 1.59)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2061084"] +hip = 61084 + +["SaR 311"] +why = "SAC's position or magnitude is off, so the cross-match finds no star, or the wrong component. Evidence: 119 Tau is HIP 25945; HD 36389 is HIP 25945's; V 4.7 fits HIP 25945 4.32, no other star within 3' does." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2025945"] +hip = 25945 + +["SaR 139"] +why = "A variable whose catalog magnitude is not Hipparcos's V, so the cross-match's V gate turns its star away. Evidence: BD +58 1772a is HIP 87820's; SIMBAD gives T Dra = BD+58 1772a = HIP 87820; 0.14' from HIP 87820. SAC gives T Dra one value, 7.2, its maximum. T Dra is a Mira; its V range is 7.2-13.5 (GCVS)." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2087820", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=T%20Dra", + "GCVS B/gcvs via VizieR (T Dra M 7.2-13.5 V)", +] +hip = 87820 +mag = [7.2, 13.5] +was.mag = 10 + +["SaR 96"] +why = "A variable whose catalog magnitude is not Hipparcos's V, so the cross-match's V gate turns its star away. Evidence: HD 58195 and BD -22 1850 are HIP 35865's; SIMBAD gives BE CMa = HD 58195 = HIP 35865; 0.62' from HIP 35865. SAC gives BE CMa V 7.0, outside its V range of 8.6-9.4 (GCVS); Hipparcos gives V 8.70 and SIMBAD 8.67." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2035865", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=BE%20CMa", + "GCVS B/gcvs via VizieR (BE CMa SRB 8.6-9.4 V)", +] +hip = 35865 +mag = [8.6, 9.4] +was.mag = 8.7 + +["SaR 187"] +why = "A variable whose catalog magnitude is not Hipparcos's V, so the cross-match's V gate turns its star away. Evidence: HD 128033 is HIP 71386's; SIMBAD gives Z Lup = HD 128033 = HIP 71386; 0.42' from HIP 71386; source's V is the error (V 7.0 vs HIP 71386 8.20, Hp 8.06-8.42). GCVS gives Z Lup only a photographic range (10.5-12.6)." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2071386", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=Z%20Lup", +] +hip = 71386 + +["SaR 155"] +why = "A variable whose catalog magnitude is not Hipparcos's V, so the cross-match's V gate turns its star away. Evidence: HD 47396 is HIP 31829's; SIMBAD gives NY Gem = HD 47396 = HIP 31829; 0.31' from HIP 31829; source's V is the error (V 9.2 vs HIP 31829 10.33, Hp 10.17-10.44; Tycho-2 V 10.56). GCVS gives NY Gem only a photographic range (12.5-<15.5)." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2031829", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NY%20Gem", +] +hip = 31829 diff --git a/astro_data/corrections/steinicke.toml b/astro_data/corrections/steinicke.toml new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3de02eed2 --- /dev/null +++ b/astro_data/corrections/steinicke.toml @@ -0,0 +1,1388 @@ +# Corrections to Steinicke's Revised NGC and IC, NI2023 (ngc_ic_m/steinicke). +# See README.md in this directory for the format. +# was values from a build of 4da2a0a2b. + +["NGC 2034"] +why = "Bica 2008 classes it a plain association (A, in LH84) with no nebula, and SIMBAD As*; Steinicke's OCL+EN adds a nebula that is not there." +sources = [ + "https://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/VizieR?-source=J/MNRAS/389/678", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%202034", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "OC" +was.obj_type = "C+N" + +["NGC 1943"] +why = "A ~220 Myr populous LMC cluster (Baumgardt 2013; Bica 2008 class C, nebula LMC-N130 only possibly superposed; SIMBAD Cl*); Steinicke's EN+OCL nebula reading is not supported. OpenNGC's GCl is the young-populous-cluster convention." +sources = [ + "https://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/VizieR?-source=J/MNRAS/430/676", + "https://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/VizieR?-source=J/MNRAS/389/678", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%201943", + "http://www.klima-luft.de/steinicke/ngcic/rev2000/Explan.htm", +] +obj_type = "OC" +was.obj_type = "C+N" + +["NGC 1839"] +why = "An ~80 Myr LMC cluster (Baumgardt 2013) with no nebula (Bica 2008 class C, SIMBAD Cl*); Dreyer's 'st + neb' was unresolved glow." +sources = [ + "https://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/VizieR?-source=J/MNRAS/430/676", + "https://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/VizieR?-source=J/MNRAS/389/678", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%201839", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "OC" +was.obj_type = "C+N" + +["NGC 361"] +why = "An old (6-8 Gyr) SMC cluster (Bica 2008 'Old IAC', class C; SIMBAD OpC) with no nebula; Steinicke's OCL+EN is wrong. Gb is arguable for its age." +sources = [ + "https://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/VizieR?-source=J/MNRAS/389/678", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%20361", + "http://www.klima-luft.de/steinicke/ngcic/rev2000/Explan.htm", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "OC" +was.obj_type = "C+N" + +["IC 2128"] +why = "LMC association with nebula: IC description 'Cl, few st and neb', Bica 2008 lists it among the emission nebulae (DNA, in Shapley-I), SIMBAD HII." +sources = [ + "https://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/VizieR?-source=J/MNRAS/389/678", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=IC%202128", + "http://www.klima-luft.de/steinicke/ngcic/rev2000/Explan.htm", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "C+N" +was.obj_type = "OC" + +["NGC 2244"] +why = "The ~4 Myr cluster (Hunt & Reffert 2023) that ionises the Rosette Nebula; Steinicke's remark 'in Rosette nebula' but class 'II3p' has no 'n'. C 50: the catalog's 06 32 19.0 +04 51 24 (Steinicke) is 7.0' from the Gaia centre (r50 6.3'), 8.1' from Corwin and 4.0' from SIMBAD, to the southeast; OpenNGC is 1.0' from the Gaia centre. Minor, but it is a Caldwell object. Structure: the catalog also keeps NGC 2239 (= NGC 2244) as a second object at the same point." +sources = [ + "https://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/VizieR?-source=J/A+A/673/A114", + "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosette_Nebula", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%202244", + "http://www.klima-luft.de/steinicke/ngcic/rev2000/Explan.htm", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", + "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/byname?objname=NGC%202244", + "https://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/VizieR-3?-source=J/A%2BA/673/A114/clusters", + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/ngconly.txt", +] +obj_type = "C+N" +ra = "06 31 56.5" +dec = "+04 55 36" +was.obj_type = "OC" +was.ra = "06 32 19.00" +was.dec = "+04 51 24.0" + +["NGC 2579"] +why = "An HII region ionised by three O stars of its embedded cluster (Copetti et al. 2007); Dreyer 'D* in pS neb, am 70 st'. Steinicke gives only a Trumpler class. Steinicke 19' is about twice every other estimate; OpenNGC's MajAx for clusters comes from HEASARC mwsc 'central_radius' (Kharchenko et al. 2013 r1) and is the radius in arcmin stored as a diameter: it equals 60*r1 exactly (0.055 deg)." +sources = [ + "https://arxiv.org/abs/0707.2062", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%202579", + "http://www.klima-luft.de/steinicke/ngcic/rev2000/Explan.htm", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", + "Kharchenko+ 2013 MWSC, VizieR J/A+A/558/A53", + "Dias+ 2002 v3.5, VizieR B/ocl", + "Lynga 1987, VizieR VII/92A", + "NGC 2000.0 (Sinnott 1988), PiFinder astro_data/ngc_ic_m/ngc2000/ngc2000.dat", + "OpenNGC README (data sources) and NGC.csv Sources column", +] +obj_type = "C+N" +size = "10'" +was.obj_type = "OC" +was.size = "19'" + +["NGC 3247"] +why = "NGC 3247 is RCW 49, a bright HII region with stars involved (Dreyer 'st inv in neb'; Steinicke 'in EN'); OpenNGC's HII is acceptable, the catalog's bare OC drops the nebula." +sources = [ + "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RCW_49", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%203247", + "http://www.klima-luft.de/steinicke/ngcic/rev2000/Explan.htm", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "C+N" +was.obj_type = "OC" + +["NGC 1921"] +why = "Bica 2008 classes both components as a cluster in nebula (CN, inside LMC-N121/DEML133): Steinicke's EN (Nb) drops the cluster, OpenNGC's OCl drops the nebula." +sources = [ + "https://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/VizieR?-source=J/MNRAS/389/678", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%201921", + "http://www.klima-luft.de/steinicke/ngcic/rev2000/Explan.htm", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "C+N" +was.obj_type = "Nb" + +["IC 1308"] +why = "An HII region inside another galaxy (M 33, M 101, NGC 6822, NGC 2403, NGC 3184, NGC 4559; NED and SIMBAD HII); Steinicke itself marks it status 6 'GxyP' (part of a galaxy), so 'Gx' wrongly makes it a separate galaxy." +sources = [ + "http://www.klima-luft.de/steinicke/ngcic/rev2000/Explan.htm", + "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NGC_604", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%20604", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%205461", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "Nb" +was.obj_type = "?" + +["IC 3551"] +why = "An HII region inside another galaxy (M 33, M 101, NGC 6822, NGC 2403, NGC 3184, NGC 4559; NED and SIMBAD HII); Steinicke itself marks it status 6 'GxyP' (part of a galaxy), so 'Gx' wrongly makes it a separate galaxy." +sources = [ + "http://www.klima-luft.de/steinicke/ngcic/rev2000/Explan.htm", + "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NGC_604", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%20604", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%205461", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "Nb" +was.obj_type = "?" + +["NGC 3181"] +why = "An HII region inside another galaxy (M 33, M 101, NGC 6822, NGC 2403, NGC 3184, NGC 4559; NED and SIMBAD HII); Steinicke itself marks it status 6 'GxyP' (part of a galaxy), so 'Gx' wrongly makes it a separate galaxy." +sources = [ + "http://www.klima-luft.de/steinicke/ngcic/rev2000/Explan.htm", + "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NGC_604", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%20604", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%205461", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "Nb" +was.obj_type = "?" + +["NGC 5447"] +why = "An HII region inside another galaxy (M 33, M 101, NGC 6822, NGC 2403, NGC 3184, NGC 4559; NED and SIMBAD HII); Steinicke itself marks it status 6 'GxyP' (part of a galaxy), so 'Gx' wrongly makes it a separate galaxy." +sources = [ + "http://www.klima-luft.de/steinicke/ngcic/rev2000/Explan.htm", + "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NGC_604", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%20604", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%205461", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "Nb" +was.obj_type = "?" + +["NGC 5449"] +why = "An HII complex/superassociation in NGC 4395 or M 101 (NED; Steinicke 'HII in N 4395'/'part of M 101', status 6), not a galaxy; OpenNGC's 'Other' is vague but not wrong (HII would be better)." +sources = [ + "http://www.klima-luft.de/steinicke/ngcic/rev2000/Explan.htm", + "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/byname?objname=NGC%204401", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%204399", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%205449", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "Nb" +was.obj_type = "?" + +["NGC 5451"] +why = "An HII region inside another galaxy (M 33, M 101, NGC 6822, NGC 2403, NGC 3184, NGC 4559; NED and SIMBAD HII); Steinicke itself marks it status 6 'GxyP' (part of a galaxy), so 'Gx' wrongly makes it a separate galaxy." +sources = [ + "http://www.klima-luft.de/steinicke/ngcic/rev2000/Explan.htm", + "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NGC_604", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%20604", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%205461", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "Nb" +was.obj_type = "?" + +["NGC 5453"] +why = "An HII region inside another galaxy (M 33, M 101, NGC 6822, NGC 2403, NGC 3184, NGC 4559; NED and SIMBAD HII); Steinicke itself marks it status 6 'GxyP' (part of a galaxy), so 'Gx' wrongly makes it a separate galaxy." +sources = [ + "http://www.klima-luft.de/steinicke/ngcic/rev2000/Explan.htm", + "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NGC_604", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%20604", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%205461", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "Nb" +was.obj_type = "?" + +["NGC 5455"] +why = "An HII region inside another galaxy (M 33, M 101, NGC 6822, NGC 2403, NGC 3184, NGC 4559; NED and SIMBAD HII); Steinicke itself marks it status 6 'GxyP' (part of a galaxy), so 'Gx' wrongly makes it a separate galaxy." +sources = [ + "http://www.klima-luft.de/steinicke/ngcic/rev2000/Explan.htm", + "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NGC_604", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%20604", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%205461", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "Nb" +was.obj_type = "?" + +["NGC 5461"] +why = "An HII region inside another galaxy (M 33, M 101, NGC 6822, NGC 2403, NGC 3184, NGC 4559; NED and SIMBAD HII); Steinicke itself marks it status 6 'GxyP' (part of a galaxy), so 'Gx' wrongly makes it a separate galaxy." +sources = [ + "http://www.klima-luft.de/steinicke/ngcic/rev2000/Explan.htm", + "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NGC_604", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%20604", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%205461", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "Nb" +was.obj_type = "?" + +["NGC 5462"] +why = "An HII region inside another galaxy (M 33, M 101, NGC 6822, NGC 2403, NGC 3184, NGC 4559; NED and SIMBAD HII); Steinicke itself marks it status 6 'GxyP' (part of a galaxy), so 'Gx' wrongly makes it a separate galaxy." +sources = [ + "http://www.klima-luft.de/steinicke/ngcic/rev2000/Explan.htm", + "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NGC_604", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%20604", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%205461", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "Nb" +was.obj_type = "?" + +["NGC 5471"] +why = "An HII region inside another galaxy (M 33, M 101, NGC 6822, NGC 2403, NGC 3184, NGC 4559; NED and SIMBAD HII); Steinicke itself marks it status 6 'GxyP' (part of a galaxy), so 'Gx' wrongly makes it a separate galaxy." +sources = [ + "http://www.klima-luft.de/steinicke/ngcic/rev2000/Explan.htm", + "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NGC_604", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%20604", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%205461", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "Nb" +was.obj_type = "?" + +["IC 142"] +why = "An HII region inside another galaxy (M 33, M 101, NGC 6822, NGC 2403, NGC 3184, NGC 4559; NED and SIMBAD HII); Steinicke itself marks it status 6 'GxyP' (part of a galaxy), so 'Gx' wrongly makes it a separate galaxy." +sources = [ + "http://www.klima-luft.de/steinicke/ngcic/rev2000/Explan.htm", + "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NGC_604", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%20604", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%205461", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "Nb" +was.obj_type = "OC" + +["NGC 206"] +why = "A stellar association/star cloud inside M 33 or M 31 (NED; Steinicke 'OCL in M 33'/'part of M 31', status 6; NGC 206 is an OB association), not a galaxy; PiFinder has no association code, OC is the nearest. OpenNGC's *Ass is right (its current master calls IC 139 a single star)." +sources = [ + "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NGC_206", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=IC%20136", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%20206", + "http://www.klima-luft.de/steinicke/ngcic/rev2000/Explan.htm", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "OC" +was.obj_type = "?" + +["IC 4685"] +why = "An emission/reflection nebula around a 7.5 mag star near NGC 6559 (IC: '*7.5 in L, dif neb'; NED 'star embedded in nebulosity'; SIMBAD ISM), not a cluster; Steinicke's 'IV3pn' cluster reading would at best give C+N. Steinicke's Trumpler class 'IV3pn' makes it C+N by the loader's rule; the object is the nebula." +sources = [ + "https://astrodrudis.com/ic-4685-and-ic-1274/", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=IC%204685", + "http://www.klima-luft.de/steinicke/ngcic/rev2000/Explan.htm", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "Nb" +was.obj_type = "C+N" + +["NGC 5120"] +why = "Steinicke's own remark identifies it with Ruprecht 166, which Hunt & Reffert (2023) confirm as a real ~11 Myr cluster within 0.5' of the position; SIMBAD OpC. The *Grp type contradicts the cross-ID." +sources = [ + "https://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/VizieR?-source=J/A+A/673/A114", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%205120", + "http://www.klima-luft.de/steinicke/ngcic/rev2000/Explan.htm", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "OC" +was.obj_type = "Ast" + +["NGC 5299"] +why = "Not a nebula: Steinicke calls it a star cloud, NED/SIMBAD/Kharchenko MWSC an open cluster (Gaia clusters UBC 295 / UBC 107 lie within 8'); OC follows OpenNGC, Ast would follow Steinicke." +sources = [ + "http://www.klima-luft.de/steinicke/ngcic/rev2000/Explan.htm", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%205299", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%206682", + "https://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/VizieR?-source=J/A+A/673/A114", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "OC" +was.obj_type = "Ast" + +["NGC 6682"] +why = "Not a nebula: Steinicke calls it a star cloud, NED/SIMBAD/Kharchenko MWSC an open cluster (Gaia clusters UBC 295 / UBC 107 lie within 8'); OC follows OpenNGC, Ast would follow Steinicke." +sources = [ + "http://www.klima-luft.de/steinicke/ngcic/rev2000/Explan.htm", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%205299", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%206682", + "https://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/VizieR?-source=J/A+A/673/A114", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "OC" +was.obj_type = "Ast" + +["M 18"] +why = "Steinicke's Trumpler class 'II3pn' makes NGC 6613 C+N by the loader's rule, but M 18 is an open cluster of about 33 Myr whose only nebulosity is a faint hint in deep images. SIMBAD types it OpC, OpenNGC OCl (Rich's decision, #676)." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=M%2018", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", + "http://www.klima-luft.de/steinicke/ngcic/rev2000/Explan.htm", +] +obj_type = "OC" +was.obj_type = "C+N" + +["IC 1311"] +why = "Steinicke's Trumpler class 'II3rn' makes it C+N by the loader's rule, but IC 1311 is an open cluster of about 1.6 Gyr, too old for a nebula of its own: the 'n' is foreground Cygnus nebulosity. SIMBAD types it OpC, OpenNGC OCl (#676)." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=IC%201311", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", + "http://www.klima-luft.de/steinicke/ngcic/rev2000/Explan.htm", +] +obj_type = "OC" +was.obj_type = "C+N" + +["M 43"] +why = "Steinicke has no Vmag; his Bmag 6.8 is NU Ori (HD 37061, V 6.83), the nebula's exciting star, so a blind fallback to Bmag would be wrong. SEDS and NGC 2000.0 give 9.0, as OpenNGC does (HEASARC messier table)." +sources = [ + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "SEDS Messier database (messier.seds.org)", + "NGC 2000.0, Sinnott 1988 (PiFinder astro_data/ngc_ic_m/ngc2000/ngc2000.dat; 'p' = photographic)", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", + "Wikipedia", +] +mag = 9 +was.mag = "" + +["M 78"] +why = "No Steinicke Vmag (Bmag 8.0); OpenNGC 8.0, NGC 2000.0 8, SEDS 8.3. Any of these serves." +sources = [ + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", + "NGC 2000.0, Sinnott 1988 (PiFinder astro_data/ngc_ic_m/ngc2000/ngc2000.dat; 'p' = photographic)", + "SEDS Messier database (messier.seds.org)", +] +mag = 8.3 +was.mag = "" + +["M 8"] +why = "No Steinicke Vmag (Bmag 5.8); OpenNGC V 5.8 (B 5.0), NGC 2000.0 5.8, SEDS 6.0." +sources = [ + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", + "NGC 2000.0, Sinnott 1988 (PiFinder astro_data/ngc_ic_m/ngc2000/ngc2000.dat; 'p' = photographic)", + "SEDS Messier database (messier.seds.org)", +] +mag = 6 +was.mag = "" + +["NGC 2070"] +why = "No Steinicke Vmag (Bmag 5.0). NGC 2000.0 8.2, Wikipedia 8; OpenNGC V 7.25 (SIMBAD), B 5.0. Inside the LMC every value here passes the page's Cloud cut of 10." +sources = [ + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "NGC 2000.0, Sinnott 1988 (PiFinder astro_data/ngc_ic_m/ngc2000/ngc2000.dat; 'p' = photographic)", + "Wikipedia", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", +] +mag = 8 +was.mag = "" + +["IC 1266"] +why = "A compact planetary with a bright central star. No Steinicke Vmag; Bmag 12.1 is photographic. Tycho-2 V 11.49 (SIMBAD, 2000A&A...355L..27H), OpenNGC V 11.2. A Bmag fallback would put it at 12.1, off the page." +sources = [ + "SIMBAD flux table, TAP query 2026-10-21", + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", +] +mag = 11.4 +was.mag = "" + +["NGC 4504"] +why = "Steinicke's B 13.9 is about 1.8 mag too faint. RC3 mB 11.89, OpenNGC/LEDA B 12.11, SIMBAD B 12.1 (2005MNRAS.361...34D), SGA g 12.09, r 11.55 (V 11.76). For an Scd, V is about 11.5-11.8; OpenNGC's 11.61 is right. Web pages giving 13.2 copy Steinicke. Cut: page: newly drawn (cut 12)." +sources = [ + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "RC3, de Vaucouleurs et al. 1991 (VizieR VII/155): BT, (B-V)T, mB", + "Siena Galaxy Atlas, Moustakas et al. 2023, ApJS 269, 3 (total g, r via SIMBAD); V = g - 0.59(g-r) - 0.01", + "SIMBAD flux table, TAP query 2026-10-21", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", +] +mag = 11.6 +was.mag = 13.2 + +["NGC 5339"] +why = "Steinicke's B 15.0 (and SIMBAD's undated B 16.5) disagree with modern photometry: OpenNGC/LEDA B 12.82, SGA g 12.81, r 12.17 (V 12.42), 2MASS K 9.70. V is about 12.2; OpenNGC's 12.24 is right." +sources = [ + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "Siena Galaxy Atlas, Moustakas et al. 2023, ApJS 269, 3 (total g, r via SIMBAD); V = g - 0.59(g-r) - 0.01", + "2MASS XSC K via SIMBAD (2006AJ....131.1163S)", + "SIMBAD flux table, TAP query 2026-10-21", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", +] +mag = 12.2 +was.mag = 14.1 + +["NGC 4861"] +why = "RC3 BT 12.9 (+-0.3), (B-V)T 0.58, VT 12.32; RC3 mB 12.54; LEDA B 12.86. Steinicke's B 14.1 is about 1.2 mag too faint (it may omit the bright HII knot Mrk 59 at the galaxy's end). OpenNGC's 12.32 is right." +sources = [ + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "RC3, de Vaucouleurs et al. 1991 (VizieR VII/155): BT, (B-V)T, mB", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", +] +mag = 12.3 +was.mag = 13.5 + +["NGC 1265"] +why = "RC3 BT 13.22, (B-V)T 1.12, VT 12.10; LEDA B 13.04. Steinicke's B 14.4 is about 1.2 mag too faint. OpenNGC's 11.92 is close." +sources = [ + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "RC3, de Vaucouleurs et al. 1991 (VizieR VII/155): BT, (B-V)T, mB", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", +] +mag = 12.1 +was.mag = 13.4 + +["NGC 3219"] +why = "Steinicke's B 14.2 is about 1 mag too bright: LEDA B 15.24, SIMBAD B 15.4, SDSS g 14.65, r 13.72 (V 14.1), 2MASS K 11.0. V is about 14.2; OpenNGC's 14.21 is right." +sources = [ + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "SIMBAD flux table, TAP query 2026-10-21", + "2MASS XSC K via SIMBAD (2006AJ....131.1163S)", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", +] +mag = 14.2 +was.mag = 13.2 + +["IC 2378"] +why = "Steinicke's B 15.3 (same as SIMBAD's undated B) is too faint: LEDA B 14.38, SDSS g 14.10, r 13.17 (V 13.55), 2MASS K 10.03 (S0, so B about 14.0). V is about 13.4; OpenNGC's 13.23 is close." +sources = [ + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "SIMBAD flux table, TAP query 2026-10-21", + "2MASS XSC K via SIMBAD (2006AJ....131.1163S)", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", +] +mag = 13.4 +was.mag = 14.3 + +["IC 1029"] +why = "Steinicke's B 13.3 (V 12.4) disagrees with the independent totals. Independent totals (V): 2MASS K 12.08, LEDA B 11.45, RC3 VT 11.29; median 11.45 (spread 0.16). Catalog 12.4 is +0.95, OpenNGC 11.29 -0.16. Cut: page: newly drawn (cut 12)." +sources = [ + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", + "RC3, de Vaucouleurs et al. 1991 (VizieR VII/155): BT, (B-V)T, mB", + "2MASS XSC K via SIMBAD (2006AJ....131.1163S)", +] +mag = 11.4 +was.mag = 12.4 + +["IC 3383"] +why = "Steinicke's B 15.0 (V 14.1) disagrees with the independent totals. Independent totals (V): SGA 14.80, 2MASS K 15.98, LEDA B 14.19; median 14.80 (spread 0.61). Catalog 14.1 is -0.70, OpenNGC 15.18 +0.38." +sources = [ + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", + "Siena Galaxy Atlas, Moustakas et al. 2023, ApJS 269, 3 (total g, r via SIMBAD); V = g - 0.59(g-r) - 0.01", + "2MASS XSC K via SIMBAD (2006AJ....131.1163S)", +] +mag = 14.8 +was.mag = 14.1 + +["NGC 3798"] +why = "Steinicke's B 13.1 (V 12.1) disagrees with the independent totals. Independent totals (V): 2MASS K 12.71, LEDA B 12.76, RC3 mB 12.15; median 12.71 (spread 0.05). Catalog 12.1 is -0.61, OpenNGC 13.1 +0.39." +sources = [ + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", + "RC3, de Vaucouleurs et al. 1991 (VizieR VII/155): BT, (B-V)T, mB", + "2MASS XSC K via SIMBAD (2006AJ....131.1163S)", +] +mag = 12.7 +was.mag = 12.1 + +["NGC 5735"] +why = "Steinicke's B 13.1 (V 12.3) disagrees with the independent totals. Independent totals (V): 2MASS K 13.38, LEDA B 12.91, RC3 mB 12.35; median 12.91 (spread 0.47). Catalog 12.3 is -0.61, OpenNGC 13.36 +0.45." +sources = [ + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", + "RC3, de Vaucouleurs et al. 1991 (VizieR VII/155): BT, (B-V)T, mB", + "2MASS XSC K via SIMBAD (2006AJ....131.1163S)", +] +mag = 12.9 +was.mag = 12.3 + +["IC 1210"] +why = "Steinicke's B 14.0 (V 13.1) disagrees with the independent totals. Independent totals (V): SGA 13.65, 2MASS K 13.91, LEDA B 14.11, RC3 mB 13.15; median 13.78 (spread 0.23). Catalog 13.1 is -0.68, OpenNGC 14.56 +0.78. OpenNGC is off too: OpenNGC's V 14.56 (B 14.96)." +sources = [ + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", + "RC3, de Vaucouleurs et al. 1991 (VizieR VII/155): BT, (B-V)T, mB", + "Siena Galaxy Atlas, Moustakas et al. 2023, ApJS 269, 3 (total g, r via SIMBAD); V = g - 0.59(g-r) - 0.01", + "2MASS XSC K via SIMBAD (2006AJ....131.1163S)", +] +mag = 13.8 +was.mag = 13.1 + +["IC 1901"] +why = "Steinicke's B 15.7 (V 14.9) disagrees with the independent totals. Independent totals (V): 2MASS K 13.56, LEDA B 14.53; median 14.05 (spread 0.48). Catalog 14.9 is +0.85, OpenNGC 16.76 +2.71. OpenNGC is off too: OpenNGC's V 16.76 is fainter than its own B 15.38 (B-V -1.38; galaxies run 0.4-1.1), so it is not a total V." +sources = [ + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", + "2MASS XSC K via SIMBAD (2006AJ....131.1163S)", +] +mag = 14 +was.mag = 14.9 + +["IC 3492"] +why = "Steinicke's B 14.8 (V 13.8) disagrees with the independent totals. Independent totals (V): SGA 14.70, 2MASS K 16.06, LEDA B 14.17, RC3 mB 14.54; median 14.62 (spread 0.27). Catalog 13.8 is -0.82, OpenNGC 15.3 +0.68. OpenNGC is off too: OpenNGC's V 15.3 is fainter than its own B 15.12 (B-V -0.18; galaxies run 0.4-1.1), so it is not a total V." +sources = [ + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", + "RC3, de Vaucouleurs et al. 1991 (VizieR VII/155): BT, (B-V)T, mB", + "Siena Galaxy Atlas, Moustakas et al. 2023, ApJS 269, 3 (total g, r via SIMBAD); V = g - 0.59(g-r) - 0.01", + "2MASS XSC K via SIMBAD (2006AJ....131.1163S)", +] +mag = 14.6 +was.mag = 13.8 + +["NGC 2718"] +why = "Steinicke's B 12.6 (V 11.8) disagrees with the independent totals. Independent totals (V): 2MASS K 12.61, LEDA B 12.47, RC3 mB 11.88; median 12.47 (spread 0.14). Catalog 11.8 is -0.67, OpenNGC 14.24 +1.77. OpenNGC is off too: OpenNGC's V 14.24 is SIMBAD's V for this galaxy, which comes from the Veron-Cetty & Veron 2010 AGN catalogue: a nuclear magnitude, not the galaxy's (OpenNGC B 13.32). Cut: page: dropped (cut 12)." +sources = [ + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", + "RC3, de Vaucouleurs et al. 1991 (VizieR VII/155): BT, (B-V)T, mB", + "2MASS XSC K via SIMBAD (2006AJ....131.1163S)", + "Veron-Cetty & Veron 2010, A&A 518, A10 (AGN catalogue; SIMBAD's V for these galaxies)", +] +mag = 12.5 +was.mag = 11.8 + +["NGC 4297"] +why = "OpenNGC's V 12.92 (LEDA B 13.86) is far too bright, probably the light of the pair with NGC 4296. SIMBAD B 16.0, SDSS g 15.57, r 14.81 (V 15.11), 2MASS K 12.29 all put V near 15.1; Steinicke's 14.6 is about 0.5 too bright, which is the wrong side of the quarter page's 15 cut. Cut: quarter: dropped (cut 15)." +sources = [ + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "SIMBAD flux table, TAP query 2026-10-21", + "2MASS XSC K via SIMBAD (2006AJ....131.1163S)", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", +] +mag = 15.1 +was.mag = 14.6 + +["NGC 1814"] +why = "NGC 2000.0 gives '9.p' for this LMC object, an old rough photographic figure that Steinicke carries as Vmag 9.0 (the same 9.0 appears for NGC 1814, 1816, 1820 and 1974). SIMBAD's modern integrated V (Bica et al. 1996 cluster photometry) is 12.76; a 1-2' LMC cluster at 9.0 would rival NGC 1850 and NGC 1866, the brightest. OpenNGC is right. Cut: page (Cloud cut): dropped (cut 10)." +sources = [ + "NGC 2000.0, Sinnott 1988 (PiFinder astro_data/ngc_ic_m/ngc2000/ngc2000.dat; 'p' = photographic)", + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "SIMBAD flux table, TAP query 2026-10-21", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", +] +mag = 12.76 +was.mag = 9 + +["NGC 1816"] +why = "NGC 2000.0 gives '9.p' for this LMC object, an old rough photographic figure that Steinicke carries as Vmag 9.0 (the same 9.0 appears for NGC 1814, 1816, 1820 and 1974). SIMBAD's modern integrated V (Bica et al. 1996 cluster photometry) is 13.02; a 1-2' LMC cluster at 9.0 would rival NGC 1850 and NGC 1866, the brightest. OpenNGC is right. Cut: page (Cloud cut): dropped (cut 10); quarter: dropped (cut 12)." +sources = [ + "NGC 2000.0, Sinnott 1988 (PiFinder astro_data/ngc_ic_m/ngc2000/ngc2000.dat; 'p' = photographic)", + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "SIMBAD flux table, TAP query 2026-10-21", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", +] +mag = 13.02 +was.mag = 9 + +["NGC 1820"] +why = "NGC 2000.0 gives '9.p' for this LMC object, an old rough photographic figure that Steinicke carries as Vmag 9.0 (the same 9.0 appears for NGC 1814, 1816, 1820 and 1974). SIMBAD's modern integrated V (Bica et al. 1996 cluster photometry) is 11.5; a 1-2' LMC cluster at 9.0 would rival NGC 1850 and NGC 1866, the brightest. OpenNGC is right. Cut: page (Cloud cut): dropped (cut 10)." +sources = [ + "NGC 2000.0, Sinnott 1988 (PiFinder astro_data/ngc_ic_m/ngc2000/ngc2000.dat; 'p' = photographic)", + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "SIMBAD flux table, TAP query 2026-10-21", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", +] +mag = 11.5 +was.mag = 9 + +["NGC 1974"] +why = "NGC 2000.0 gives '9.p' for this LMC object, an old rough photographic figure that Steinicke carries as Vmag 9.0 (the same 9.0 appears for NGC 1814, 1816, 1820 and 1974). SIMBAD's modern integrated V (Bica et al. 1996 cluster photometry) is 10.3; a 1-2' LMC cluster at 9.0 would rival NGC 1850 and NGC 1866, the brightest. OpenNGC is right. Cut: page (Cloud cut): dropped (cut 10)." +sources = [ + "NGC 2000.0, Sinnott 1988 (PiFinder astro_data/ngc_ic_m/ngc2000/ngc2000.dat; 'p' = photographic)", + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "SIMBAD flux table, TAP query 2026-10-21", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", +] +mag = 10.3 +was.mag = 9 + +["NGC 1938"] +why = "Steinicke's V 11.8 is that of its brighter neighbour NGC 1939 (OpenNGC V 11.83, B 12.52); NGC 1938 itself has SIMBAD V 13.09, B 13.54. Cut: quarter: dropped (cut 12)." +sources = [ + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "SIMBAD flux table, TAP query 2026-10-21", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", +] +mag = 13.1 +was.mag = 11.8 + +["NGC 1847"] +why = "SIMBAD's integrated V 12.469, B 12.508 (CCD, three decimals) against Steinicke's 11.1, which has no source in NGC 2000.0. Moderate confidence: LMC integrated magnitudes depend on aperture. Cut: quarter: dropped (cut 12)." +sources = [ + "SIMBAD flux table, TAP query 2026-10-21", + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", +] +mag = 12.5 +was.mag = 11.1 + +["NGC 7513"] +why = "RC3's V-coded BT of 11.39, which the RC3 supplementary source gives it, is the low outlier among the independent totals (2MASS 12.08, LEDA 11.85, ESO-LV 11.98). 11.9 is the audit's median of the four, spread 0.12 (Rich's decision, #681)." +sources = [ + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", + "RC3, de Vaucouleurs et al. 1991 (VizieR VII/155): BT, (B-V)T, mB", + "2MASS XSC K via SIMBAD (2006AJ....131.1163S)", + "ESO-LV, Lauberts & Valentijn 1989 (via SIMBAD)", +] +mag = 11.9 +was.mag = 11.4 + +["NGC 4874"] +why = "Steinicke's rows for NGC 4872 and NGC 4874 are swapped: his 'NGC 4872' row is the Coma cD galaxy NGC 4874, with its position, size and V 11.7 (RC3 VT 11.68). Position Corwin's; size about 2.0' (RC3 1.95', UGC 2.4', SDSS 1.9', NGC 2000.0 2.7')." +sources = [ + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/ngconly.txt", + "RC3, VizieR VII/155", + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "RC3, de Vaucouleurs et al. 1991 (VizieR VII/155): BT, (B-V)T, mB", + "Siena Galaxy Atlas, Moustakas et al. 2023, ApJS 269, 3 (total g, r via SIMBAD); V = g - 0.59(g-r) - 0.01", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", +] +ra = "12 59 35.71" +dec = "+27 57 33.3" +size = "2.0'x2.0'" +mag = 11.7 +was.ra = "12 59 34.30" +was.dec = "+27 56 48.0" +was.size = "30\"x18\"" +was.mag = 14.4 + +["NGC 4872"] +why = "Steinicke's rows for NGC 4872 and NGC 4874 are swapped: his 'NGC 4874' row (12 59 34.3 +27 56 48, 0.5'x0.3', V 14.4) is NGC 4872, and NGC 4872's V is 14.4 (RC3 VT 14.41)." +sources = [ + "RC3, VizieR VII/155", + "Steinicke Revised NGC/IC as PiFinder ships it (astro_data/ngc_ic_m/steinicke/steinicke_catalog.json: Bmag, Vmag)", + "RC3, de Vaucouleurs et al. 1991 (VizieR VII/155): BT, (B-V)T, mB", + "SIMBAD flux table, TAP query 2026-10-21", + "OpenNGC NGC.csv B-Mag, V-Mag and Sources (starplot-ongc v0.1.2 copy; starplot's magnitude is V-Mag only)", +] +ra = "12 59 34.3" +dec = "+27 56 48" +size = "0.5'x0.3'" +mag = 14.4 +was.ra = "12 59 35.80" +was.dec = "+27 57 34.0" +was.size = "1.9'x1.9'" +was.mag = 11.7 + +["IC 501"] +why = "Steinicke 0.2', well below every isophotal measure; OpenNGC (HyperLEDA) agrees with the correct value. Steinicke often falls back on MCG/CGCG eye estimates of the inner part." +sources = [ + "NED diameters (RC3 D25, UGC, MCG, ESO, 2MASS, SDSS)", + "RC3, VizieR VII/155", + "PGC 2003, VizieR VII/237", + "NGC 2000.0", +] +size = "0.7'x0.5'" +was.size = "12\"x12\"" + +["IC 1062"] +why = "Steinicke 0.3' (as NGC 2000.0), well below every isophotal measure; OpenNGC (HyperLEDA) agrees with the correct value. Steinicke often falls back on MCG/CGCG eye estimates of the inner part." +sources = [ + "NED diameters (RC3 D25, UGC, MCG, ESO, 2MASS, SDSS)", + "RC3, VizieR VII/155", + "PGC 2003, VizieR VII/237", + "NGC 2000.0", +] +size = "0.9'x0.7'" +was.size = "18\"x12\"" + +["IC 1391"] +why = "Steinicke 0.2' is MCG's inner diameter, well below every isophotal measure; OpenNGC (HyperLEDA) agrees with the correct value. Steinicke often falls back on MCG/CGCG eye estimates of the inner part." +sources = [ + "NED diameters (RC3 D25, UGC, MCG, ESO, 2MASS, SDSS)", + "RC3, VizieR VII/155", + "PGC 2003, VizieR VII/237", + "NGC 2000.0", +] +size = "0.7'x0.5'" +was.size = "12\"x12\"" + +["IC 1635"] +why = "Steinicke 0.3' is MCG's outer diameter, well below every isophotal measure; OpenNGC (HyperLEDA) agrees with the correct value. Steinicke often falls back on MCG/CGCG eye estimates of the inner part." +sources = [ + "NED diameters (RC3 D25, UGC, MCG, ESO, 2MASS, SDSS)", + "RC3, VizieR VII/155", + "PGC 2003, VizieR VII/237", + "NGC 2000.0", +] +size = "1.1'x0.7'" +was.size = "18\"x18\"" + +["IC 3410"] +why = "Steinicke 0.2', well below every isophotal measure; OpenNGC (HyperLEDA) agrees with the correct value. Steinicke often falls back on MCG/CGCG eye estimates of the inner part." +sources = [ + "NED diameters (RC3 D25, UGC, MCG, ESO, 2MASS, SDSS)", + "RC3, VizieR VII/155", + "PGC 2003, VizieR VII/237", + "NGC 2000.0", +] +size = "0.7'x0.6'" +was.size = "12\"x12\"" + +["IC 5351"] +why = "Steinicke 0.5', well below every isophotal measure; OpenNGC (HyperLEDA) agrees with the correct value. Steinicke often falls back on MCG/CGCG eye estimates of the inner part." +sources = [ + "NED diameters (RC3 D25, UGC, MCG, ESO, 2MASS, SDSS)", + "RC3, VizieR VII/155", + "PGC 2003, VizieR VII/237", + "NGC 2000.0", +] +size = "1.6'x0.8'" +was.size = "30\"x24\"" + +["NGC 5759"] +why = "Steinicke 0.3'x0.2' is MCG's outer diameter, well below every isophotal measure; OpenNGC (HyperLEDA) agrees with the correct value. Steinicke often falls back on MCG/CGCG eye estimates of the inner part." +sources = [ + "NED diameters (RC3 D25, UGC, MCG, ESO, 2MASS, SDSS)", + "RC3, VizieR VII/155", + "PGC 2003, VizieR VII/237", + "NGC 2000.0", +] +size = "1.1'x0.5'" +was.size = "18\"x12\"" + +["NGC 6810"] +why = "Steinicke 1.2'x0.9', well below every isophotal measure; OpenNGC (HyperLEDA) agrees with the correct value. Steinicke often falls back on MCG/CGCG eye estimates of the inner part." +sources = [ + "NED diameters (RC3 D25, UGC, MCG, ESO, 2MASS, SDSS)", + "RC3, VizieR VII/155", + "PGC 2003, VizieR VII/237", + "NGC 2000.0", +] +size = "3.2'x0.9'" +was.size = "1.2'x0.9'" + +["NGC 7317"] +why = "Two different objects are compared: the atlas joined OpenNGC's NGC 7318A/B rows to the catalog's NGC 7317 through the shared name \"Stephan's Quintet\" (these rows are not drawn; the NGC 7317 row is nearer). But the catalog's 0.4'x0.4' for NGC 7317 (MCG's outer diameter) is itself wrong. Same error in both findings." +sources = [ + "NED diameters (RC3 D25, UGC, MCG, ESO, 2MASS, SDSS)", + "RC3, VizieR VII/155", + "PGC 2003, VizieR VII/237", + "NGC 2000.0", +] +size = "1.1'x1.1'" +was.size = "24\"x24\"" + +["IC 3022"] +why = "Steinicke 2.9'x0.9' is twice any measure; OpenNGC 0.2' (and NGC 2000.0 0.2') is MCG's inner diameter." +sources = [ + "NED diameters (RC3 D25, UGC, MCG, ESO, 2MASS, SDSS)", + "RC3, VizieR VII/155", + "PGC 2003, VizieR VII/237", + "NGC 2000.0", +] +size = "1.2'x1.1'" +was.size = "2.9'x0.9'" + +["IC 4461"] +why = "Steinicke 1.3'x0.7' is about twice the measures (possibly UGC 9384's pair size, with IC 4462); OpenNGC 0.41' is half." +sources = [ + "NED diameters (RC3 D25, UGC, MCG, ESO, 2MASS, SDSS)", + "RC3, VizieR VII/155", + "PGC 2003, VizieR VII/237", + "NGC 2000.0", +] +size = "0.8'x0.5'" +was.size = "1.3'x0.7'" + +["IC 4732"] +why = "Steinicke 13\" is several times every measured extent of this near-stellar planetary; OpenNGC (Acker) is right. Info box only." +sources = [ + "Acker+ 1992, VizieR V/84", + "Tylenda+ 2003, VizieR J/A+A/405/627", + "SIMBAD dimensions", + "Wikipedia/arXiv for IC 4997 and IC 5117", +] +size = "4\"" +was.size = "13.2\"" + +["IC 4846"] +why = "Steinicke 11\" is several times every measured extent of this near-stellar planetary; OpenNGC (Acker) is right. Info box only." +sources = [ + "Acker+ 1992, VizieR V/84", + "Tylenda+ 2003, VizieR J/A+A/405/627", + "SIMBAD dimensions", + "Wikipedia/arXiv for IC 4997 and IC 5117", +] +size = "0.05'" +was.size = "10.8\"" + +["IC 4997"] +why = "Steinicke 13\" is several times every measured extent of this near-stellar planetary; OpenNGC (Acker) is right. Info box only." +sources = [ + "Acker+ 1992, VizieR V/84", + "Tylenda+ 2003, VizieR J/A+A/405/627", + "SIMBAD dimensions", + "Wikipedia/arXiv for IC 4997 and IC 5117", +] +size = "3\"" +was.size = "13.2\"" + +["IC 5117"] +why = "Steinicke 12\" is several times every measured extent of this near-stellar planetary; OpenNGC (Acker) is right. Info box only." +sources = [ + "Acker+ 1992, VizieR V/84", + "Tylenda+ 2003, VizieR J/A+A/405/627", + "SIMBAD dimensions", + "Wikipedia/arXiv for IC 4997 and IC 5117", +] +size = "2\"" +was.size = "12\"" + +["NGC 6644"] +why = "Steinicke 12\" is several times every measured extent of this near-stellar planetary; OpenNGC (Acker) is right. Info box only." +sources = [ + "Acker+ 1992, VizieR V/84", + "Tylenda+ 2003, VizieR J/A+A/405/627", + "SIMBAD dimensions", + "Wikipedia/arXiv for IC 4997 and IC 5117", +] +size = "0.08'" +was.size = "12\"" + +["NGC 6807"] +why = "Steinicke 8\" is several times every measured extent of this near-stellar planetary; OpenNGC (Acker) is right. Info box only." +sources = [ + "Acker+ 1992, VizieR V/84", + "Tylenda+ 2003, VizieR J/A+A/405/627", + "SIMBAD dimensions", + "Wikipedia/arXiv for IC 4997 and IC 5117", +] +size = "2.6\"" +was.size = "7.8\"" + +["NGC 6833"] +why = "Steinicke 11\" is several times every measured extent of this near-stellar planetary; OpenNGC (Acker) is right. Info box only." +sources = [ + "Acker+ 1992, VizieR V/84", + "Tylenda+ 2003, VizieR J/A+A/405/627", + "SIMBAD dimensions", + "Wikipedia/arXiv for IC 4997 and IC 5117", +] +size = "2\"" +was.size = "10.8\"" + +["NGC 395"] +why = "Steinicke 17'; NGC 2000.0 'group of about 10 st, no neb', no size: about ten times Bica et al. 2008, which OpenNGC carries (a decimal slip in NI2023.xls, read unchanged by the loader)." +sources = [ + "Bica+ 2008 via OpenNGC (HEASARC lmcextobj/smcclustrs)", + "NGC 2000.0", + "Steinicke NI2023.xls", +] +size = "1.5'x1.1'" +was.size = "17'" + +["NGC 602"] +why = "Steinicke 34' for a 3' cluster in N 90; NGC 2000.0 'B, S, R', no size: about ten times Bica et al. 2008, which OpenNGC carries (a decimal slip in NI2023.xls, read unchanged by the loader)." +sources = [ + "Bica+ 2008 via OpenNGC (HEASARC lmcextobj/smcclustrs)", + "NGC 2000.0", + "Steinicke NI2023.xls", +] +size = "3.2'x2.9'" +was.size = "34'" + +["NGC 1869"] +why = "Steinicke 14'; NGC 2000.0 no size: about ten times Bica et al. 2008, which OpenNGC carries (a decimal slip in NI2023.xls, read unchanged by the loader)." +sources = [ + "Bica+ 2008 via OpenNGC (HEASARC lmcextobj/smcclustrs)", + "NGC 2000.0", + "Steinicke NI2023.xls", +] +size = "2.0'x1.4'" +was.size = "14'" + +["IC 424"] +why = "Steinicke's 120' is a 2 degree cloud; IC 424 is Fleming's small nebula near delta Ori, catalogued by Dorschner-Gurtler (DG 59) and Magakian as a small cometary nebula; LBN 914 2'x2'; NGC 2000.0 gives no size. With no magnitude, the nebula rule then drops it from the page (2.5' < 5')." +sources = [ + "Magakian 2003, VizieR J/A+A/399/141", + "LBN, VizieR VII/9", + "OpenNGC note 'Dimensions from LEDA are wrong, values inferred by author'", + "Corwin IC notes (IC 434)", +] +size = "2.5'" +was.size = "2°" + +["IC 1995"] +why = "One of Barnard's exterior nebulosities of the Pleiades, around HD 23985. Steinicke 135'x135' overstates it; OpenNGC's 2' (SIMBAD) is only the part next to the star." +sources = [ + "Corwin, IC notes (IC 1995)", + "NGC 2000.0 '*6 in eF, eeL neb'", + "Cederblad 22, VizieR VII/231", +] +size = "60'x30'" +was.size = "135'x135'" + +["NGC 6526"] +why = "Corwin: NGC 6526 is the part of M 8 south-east of the dark lane, a region tens of arcminutes across; Steinicke's 6'x3' is a single knot. With no outline, the atlas then draws it as the largest nebula symbol inside M 8." +sources = [ + "Corwin NGC notes (NGC 6526)", + "NGC 2000.0", +] +size = "40'" +was.size = "6'x3'" + +["NGC 2455"] +why = "Steinicke 15' is about twice every visual estimate (only MWSC 2*r2 16.8' is as large); OpenNGC's MajAx for clusters comes from HEASARC mwsc 'central_radius' (Kharchenko et al. 2013 r1) and is the radius in arcmin stored as a diameter: it equals 60*r1 exactly (0.075 deg)." +sources = [ + "Kharchenko+ 2013 MWSC, VizieR J/A+A/558/A53", + "Dias+ 2002 v3.5, VizieR B/ocl", + "Lynga 1987, VizieR VII/92A", + "NGC 2000.0 (Sinnott 1988), PiFinder astro_data/ngc_ic_m/ngc2000/ngc2000.dat", + "OpenNGC README (data sources) and NGC.csv Sources column", +] +size = "8'" +was.size = "15'" + +["NGC 6605"] +why = "Steinicke 29' is twice Corwin's 15'x15'; OpenNGC's MajAx for clusters comes from HEASARC mwsc 'central_radius' (Kharchenko et al. 2013 r1) and is the radius in arcmin stored as a diameter: it equals 60*r1 exactly (0.105 deg)." +sources = [ + "Kharchenko+ 2013 MWSC, VizieR J/A+A/558/A53", + "Dias+ 2002 v3.5, VizieR B/ocl", + "Lynga 1987, VizieR VII/92A", + "NGC 2000.0 (Sinnott 1988), PiFinder astro_data/ngc_ic_m/ngc2000/ngc2000.dat", + "OpenNGC README (data sources) and NGC.csv Sources column", + "Corwin, NGC notes (NGC 6605)", +] +size = "15'" +was.size = "29'" + +["NGC 6625"] +why = "Steinicke's 39' exceeds every other estimate; OpenNGC's MajAx for clusters comes from HEASARC mwsc 'central_radius' (Kharchenko et al. 2013 r1) and is the radius in arcmin stored as a diameter: it equals 60*r1 exactly (0.10 deg). The identification is uncertain (Corwin). The catalog sits near the nominal position, where Corwin finds nothing obvious. Corwin's probable (':') cluster (12' x 8') is 7' west-northwest, 1.2' from OpenNGC's point (taken from SIMBAD, Kharchenko 2013)." +sources = [ + "Kharchenko+ 2013 MWSC, VizieR J/A+A/558/A53", + "Dias+ 2002 v3.5, VizieR B/ocl", + "Lynga 1987, VizieR VII/92A", + "NGC 2000.0 (Sinnott 1988), PiFinder astro_data/ngc_ic_m/ngc2000/ngc2000.dat", + "OpenNGC README (data sources) and NGC.csv Sources column", + "Corwin, NGC notes (NGC 6625)", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%206625", + "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/byname?objname=NGC%206625", + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/ngconly.txt", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +ra = "18 22 45" +dec = "-11 58 24" +size = "15'" +was.ra = "18 23 12.80" +was.dec = "-12 00 47.0" +was.size = "39'" + +["IC 1871"] +why = "The catalog has no size (Steinicke blank). OpenNGC's LBN value is right." +sources = [ + "LBN, VizieR VII/9", + "NGC 2000.0", + "Corwin notes", +] +size = "4'x4'" +was.size = "" + +["NGC 2246"] +why = "The catalog has no size (Steinicke blank). OpenNGC's value is reasonable." +sources = [ + "LBN, VizieR VII/9", + "NGC 2000.0", + "Corwin notes", +] +size = "10'" +was.size = "" + +["NGC 1986"] +why = "Steinicke 0.7' vs Bica 2.8'x2.4' ('B, pL' in NGC 2000.0): Steinicke gives the cluster's core; Bica the cluster's extent, which matches the NGC descriptions. Bica's axes are 2.8'x2.4'; the Bica supplementary source only fills a missing size, so it cannot replace Steinicke's core." +sources = [ + "https://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/VizieR?-source=J/MNRAS/389/678", + "Bica+ 2008 via OpenNGC (HEASARC lmcextobj/smcclustrs)", + "NGC 2000.0", + "Steinicke NI2023.xls", +] +size = "2.8'x2.4'" +was.size = "42\"" + +["NGC 2016"] +why = "Steinicke 0.3' vs Bica 1.8' ('F, vL' in NGC 2000.0): Steinicke gives the cluster's core; Bica the cluster's extent, which matches the NGC descriptions. Bica's axes are 1.8'x1.8'; the Bica supplementary source only fills a missing size, so it cannot replace Steinicke's core." +sources = [ + "https://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/VizieR?-source=J/MNRAS/389/678", + "Bica+ 2008 via OpenNGC (HEASARC lmcextobj/smcclustrs)", + "NGC 2000.0", + "Steinicke NI2023.xls", +] +size = "1.8'x1.8'" +was.size = "18\"" + +["NGC 2027"] +why = "Steinicke 0.7' vs Bica 4.6'x2.8' ('Cl, vL, Ri' in NGC 2000.0): Steinicke gives the cluster's core; Bica the cluster's extent, which matches the NGC descriptions. Bica's axes are 4.6'x2.8'; the Bica supplementary source only fills a missing size, so it cannot replace Steinicke's core." +sources = [ + "https://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/VizieR?-source=J/MNRAS/389/678", + "Bica+ 2008 via OpenNGC (HEASARC lmcextobj/smcclustrs)", + "NGC 2000.0", + "Steinicke NI2023.xls", +] +size = "4.6'x2.8'" +was.size = "42\"" + +["NGC 2037"] +why = "Steinicke 0.5' vs Bica 2.9'x1.3': Steinicke gives the cluster's core; Bica the cluster's extent, which matches the NGC descriptions. Bica's axes are 2.9'x1.3'; the Bica supplementary source only fills a missing size, so it cannot replace Steinicke's core." +sources = [ + "https://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/VizieR?-source=J/MNRAS/389/678", + "Bica+ 2008 via OpenNGC (HEASARC lmcextobj/smcclustrs)", + "NGC 2000.0", + "Steinicke NI2023.xls", +] +size = "2.9'x1.3'" +was.size = "30\"" + +["NGC 2041"] +why = "Steinicke 0.7' vs Bica 2.6'x2.6': Steinicke gives the cluster's core; Bica the cluster's extent, which matches the NGC descriptions. Bica's axes are 2.6'x2.6'; the Bica supplementary source only fills a missing size, so it cannot replace Steinicke's core." +sources = [ + "https://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/VizieR?-source=J/MNRAS/389/678", + "Bica+ 2008 via OpenNGC (HEASARC lmcextobj/smcclustrs)", + "NGC 2000.0", + "Steinicke NI2023.xls", +] +size = "2.6'x2.6'" +was.size = "42\"" + +["NGC 2029"] +why = "Steinicke gives no size. Bica et al. 2008's row at NGC 2029's position (05 35 39 -66 01 50) is named NGC2030: Corwin notes that NGC 2029 and NGC 2030 have their positions interchanged in the GC and NGC, and that ESO and KMHK followed the swap. Steinicke's identifications agree with Corwin's, so the size is that row's, 1.7'x1.7'." +sources = [ + "https://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/VizieR?-source=J/MNRAS/389/678", + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/ngconly.txt", + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/ngcnotes.all", +] +size = "1.7'x1.7'" +was.size = "" + +["NGC 2030"] +why = "Steinicke gives no size. Bica et al. 2008's row at NGC 2030's position (05 34 59 -67 33 23) is named NGC2029: Corwin notes that NGC 2029 and NGC 2030 have their positions interchanged in the GC and NGC, and that ESO and KMHK followed the swap. Steinicke's identifications agree with Corwin's, so the size is that row's, 1.1'x0.85'." +sources = [ + "https://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/VizieR?-source=J/MNRAS/389/678", + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/ngconly.txt", + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/ngcnotes.all", +] +size = "1.1'x0.85'" +was.size = "" + +["NGC 1404"] +why = "NGC 1404 sits within seconds of arc of the Fornax/Eridanus boundary, the parallel -36 00 00 (B1875) between RA 3h30m and 3h45m. At the modern position (03 38 51.9 -35 35 39, SIMBAD/Corwin) it is south of the line: B1875 dec -36 00 03 (skyfield) / -36 00 08 (astropy), so Eridanus, as OpenNGC says. The catalog's Steinicke position is 6\" north (-35 35 34), and skyfield's B1875 precession puts that at -35 59 58, just inside Fornax. Using the modern position flips it to Eridanus with either tool." +sources = [ + "https://cdsarc.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/cat/VI/42", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%201404", + "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/byname?objname=NGC%201404", +] +const = "Eri" +was.const = "For" + +["IC 346"] +why = "Corwin gives IC 346 a firm identification, the galaxy at OpenNGC's position, as do SIMBAD and NED. Steinicke marks IC 346 'not found' (status 10) at a nominal position (Corwin's 'IC 346.1' nominal, 'comparison star misidentified?'), and PiFinder imports it as an unknown-type object at empty sky. Identified, it no longer leads its description with Steinicke's not-found note." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=IC%20346", + "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/byname?objname=IC%20346", + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/iconly.txt", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "Gx" +ra = "03 41 44.7" +dec = "-18 16 01" +size = "1.95'x1.47'" +description = "eF, pL, E 80deg , dif" +was.obj_type = "?" +was.ra = "03 41 24.90" +was.dec = "-18 22 16.0" +was.size = "" +was.description = "Not found: nothing at Dreyer's position (Steinicke).\neF, pL, E 80deg , dif" + +["IC 3056"] +why = "Steinicke marks IC 3056 not found (status 10) at a nominal position 58' (one degree of declination) north. Corwin (firm), SIMBAD and NED all identify UGC 7249 at OpenNGC's position. The wrong position also puts the catalog's IC 3056 in Coma Berenices instead of Virgo. Identified, it no longer leads its description with Steinicke's not-found note." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=IC%203056", + "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/byname?objname=IC%203056", + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/iconly.txt", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "Gx" +ra = "12 14 36.9" +dec = "+12 48 43" +size = "1.3'x0.5'" +description = "pL, vmE 50deg" +was.obj_type = "?" +was.ra = "12 14 37.90" +was.dec = "+13 46 47.0" +was.size = "" +was.description = "Not found: nothing at Dreyer's position (Steinicke).\npL, vmE 50deg" + +["IC 4991"] +why = "Steinicke: not found (status 10), with the remark 'ESO 340-11 ?'; PiFinder stores the nominal position, where Corwin says there is nothing. Corwin's candidate, SIMBAD and NED all give ESO 340-11 at OpenNGC's position. Identified, it no longer leads its description with Steinicke's not-found note." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=IC%204991", + "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/byname?objname=IC%204991", + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/iconly.txt", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "Gx" +ra = "20 18 23.3" +dec = "-41 03 01" +size = "2.9'x2.1'" +description = "vF, cS, R" +was.obj_type = "?" +was.ra = "20 17 45.70" +was.dec = "-41 34 55.0" +was.size = "" +was.description = "Not found: nothing at Dreyer's position (Steinicke).\nvF, cS, R" + +["NGC 4323"] +why = "Steinicke gives NGC 4322 to the galaxy UGC 7450 and marks NGC 4323 not found. Corwin (firm), NED and OpenNGC give NGC 4323 to the galaxy and NGC 4322 to a star 4.8' west; SIMBAD puts both names on the galaxy. The catalog's NGC 4323 is an empty nominal point 3.4' east of the galaxy. V 13.9 is Steinicke's own for the galaxy, on his NGC 4322 row (UGC 7450). Identified, it no longer leads its description with Steinicke's not-found note." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%204323", + "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/byname?objname=NGC%204323", + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/ngconly.txt", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "Gx" +ra = "12 23 01.7" +dec = "+15 54 20" +size = "1.23'x0.71'" +mag = 13.9 +description = "2nd of 2, vF, n of M100; = 4322?" +was.obj_type = "?" +was.ra = "12 23 16.00" +was.dec = "+15 54 07.0" +was.size = "" +was.mag = "" +was.description = "Not found: nothing at Dreyer's position (Steinicke).\n2nd of 2, vF, n of M100; = 4322?" + +["NGC 6847"] +why = "Steinicke: not found (status 10); PiFinder stores 19 56 33.7 +29 13 27, 59' south of any candidate, typed unknown. Corwin's candidate (a 19' x 13' star cloud), SIMBAD (open cluster), NED and Hunt & Reffert 2023 (cluster NGC 6847, r50 1.7') all sit at OpenNGC's position, about one degree of declination north. The wrong position also gives the catalog Vulpecula instead of Cygnus. A cluster with nebulosity: SIMBAD and Hunt & Reffert 2023 give the cluster, LBN 151 the 10'x10' nebula, OpenNGC Cl+N (Rich's decision). Identified, it no longer leads its description with Steinicke's not-found note." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%206847", + "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/byname?objname=NGC%206847", + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/ngconly.txt", + "https://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/VizieR-3?-source=J/A%2BA/673/A114/clusters", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "C+N" +ra = "19 56 37.8" +dec = "+30 12 47" +size = "10'x10'" +description = "neb, r" +was.obj_type = "?" +was.ra = "19 56 33.70" +was.dec = "+29 13 27.0" +was.size = "" +was.description = "Not found: nothing at Dreyer's position (Steinicke).\nneb, r" + +["IC 2477"] +why = "Steinicke: not found (status 10) at the nominal position, which Corwin confirms is empty ('18 seconds off if = IC 2480'). Corwin's probable identification is IC 2477 = IC 2480, OpenNGC's position (OpenNGC lists IC 2480 as its duplicate). Structure: the catalog should put IC 2477 on its IC 2480 object instead of a separate empty-sky object. Identified, it no longer leads its description with Steinicke's not-found note." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=IC%202477", + "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/byname?objname=IC%202477", + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/iconly.txt", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +same_as = "IC 2480" +description = "F, S, gbM, r" +was.description = "Not found: nothing at Dreyer's position (Steinicke).\nF, S, gbM, r" + +["IC 919"] +why = "Corwin's probable (':') identification, SIMBAD and NED all agree on PGC 48570 at OpenNGC's position. Steinicke's PGC 2507977 is 5' away, near the nominal position." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=IC%20919", + "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/byname?objname=IC%20919", + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/iconly.txt", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +ra = "13 42 47.5" +dec = "+55 31 17" +was.ra = "13 42 56.50" +was.dec = "+55 36 12.0" + +["IC 4494"] +why = "Corwin ranks OpenNGC's galaxy first (':') and the catalog's second ('::'); SIMBAD and NED both choose OpenNGC's. Steinicke alone chooses PGC 52645, 4.2' south. Weak call: both are probable." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=IC%204494", + "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/byname?objname=IC%204494", + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/iconly.txt", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +ra = "14 44 25.5" +dec = "+15 33 05" +was.ra = "14 44 27.10" +was.dec = "+15 28 52.0" + +["NGC 6174"] +why = "Corwin's probable (':') identification, SIMBAD and NED all give the pair at OpenNGC's position; Steinicke's PGC 58334 is 4.5' west and not among Corwin's candidates." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%206174", + "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/byname?objname=NGC%206174", + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/ngconly.txt", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +ra = "16 29 46.6" +dec = "+40 52 24" +was.ra = "16 29 23.80" +was.dec = "+40 52 30.0" + +["NGC 4230"] +why = "Corwin's firm identification and the nominal position (6' cluster) agree with OpenNGC and NED. The catalog's position (12 17 16 -55 05.2) is 12' north, close to Kharchenko's object that SIMBAD flags 'err' and NED says is ESO 171-SC14, 'not NGC 4230'." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%204230", + "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/byname?objname=NGC%204230", + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/ngconly.txt", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +ra = "12 17 07" +dec = "-55 17 30" +was.ra = "12 17 16.00" +was.dec = "-55 05 12.0" + +["IC 998"] +why = "Corwin's candidate and both nominal positions, and NED, put IC 998 at OpenNGC's position. The catalog's IC 998 (Steinicke PGC 51220) sits on the IC 997 pair (0.0' from it), so two catalog objects are shifted by one. Steinicke's IC 998 row (PGC 51220) is the IC 997 pair, so its magnitude and size go to IC 997 with it; no source gives LEDA 1058483's, so they are cleared." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=IC%20998", + "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/byname?objname=IC%20998", + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/iconly.txt", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +ra = "14 20 19.3" +dec = "-04 24 59" +size = "" +mag = "" +was.ra = "14 19 59.20" +was.dec = "-04 27 08.0" +was.size = "1.4'x0.7'" +was.mag = 12.8 + +["IC 997"] +why = "Corwin (':'), SIMBAD and NED identify IC 997 as the pair at OpenNGC's position. Steinicke puts IC 997 on PGC 51173 ('= IC 4401') 8.8' west and moves IC 998 onto the IC 997 pair. IC 4401 keeps PGC 51173. Its split copies PGC 51173's magnitude and size; the pair's are those of Steinicke's IC 998 row, PGC 51220, which is the pair: V 12.8, 1.4'x0.7'." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=IC%20997", + "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/byname?objname=IC%20997", + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/iconly.txt", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +own_object = true +ra = "14 19 59.5" +dec = "-04 27 06" +size = "1.4'x0.7'" +mag = 12.8 +was.ra = "14 19 25.10" +was.dec = "-04 29 24.0" +was.size = "1.4'x0.5'" +was.mag = 14.2 + +["IC 1795"] +why = "Steinicke equates IC 1795 with NGC 896 (status 8), so the catalog puts IC 1795 on NGC 896's position (02 25 27.8 +62 01 10, 0.0' from the catalog's NGC 896). Corwin, NED and OpenNGC list them separately, IC 1795 7.6' east; OpenNGC also lists NGC 896 at the catalog's position. A 10-12' nebula, so the catalog's point is off it." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=IC%201795", + "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/byname?objname=IC%201795", + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/iconly.txt", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +own_object = true +ra = "02 26 33" +dec = "+62 02 30" +was.ra = "02 25 27.80" +was.dec = "+62 01 10.0" + +["IC 5281"] +why = "Corwin (firm), NED and OpenNGC identify IC 5281 as a double star. Steinicke (status 8) and SIMBAD equate it with NGC 7466, so the catalog's IC 5281 is a second object on top of NGC 7466. The split copies NGC 7466's magnitude and size, which a double star does not have, so they are cleared." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=IC%205281", + "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/byname?objname=IC%205281", + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/iconly.txt", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +own_object = true +obj_type = "D*" +ra = "23 02 23.5" +dec = "+27 00 21" +size = "" +mag = "" +was.obj_type = "Gx" +was.ra = "23 02 03.40" +was.dec = "+27 03 11.0" +was.size = "1.5'x0.5'" +was.mag = 13.5 + +["NGC 4322"] +why = "Pair with NGC 4323: Corwin (firm) and NED identify NGC 4322 as a star 4.8' west of UGC 7450; the catalog (Steinicke) puts NGC 4322 on the galaxy that is NGC 4323. The galaxy's data (type, mag 12.5-ish, size) belong on NGC 4323. The galaxy's magnitude and size go to NGC 4323 with its identification; no source gives the star's, so they are cleared." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%204322", + "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/byname?objname=NGC%204322", + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/ngconly.txt", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +obj_type = "*" +ra = "12 22 41.9" +dec = "+15 54 12" +size = "" +mag = "" +was.obj_type = "Gx" +was.ra = "12 23 01.70" +was.dec = "+15 54 19.0" +was.size = "1.1'x0.8'" +was.mag = 13.9 + +["NGC 4362"] +why = "Steinicke makes NGC 4362 a duplicate of NGC 4358 (status 7); Corwin (NGC 4362 = NGC 4364), OpenNGC/NED and SIMBAD's NGC 4362 put it on the second galaxy. The catalog has the right position already, under NGC 4364; NGC 4362 should be an entry on that object." +sources = [ + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/ngconly.txt", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%204362", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", +] +same_as = "NGC 4364" + +["NGC 6138"] +why = "Steinicke makes NGC 6363 a duplicate of NGC 6138, but puts his NGC 6138 row on the galaxy that Corwin identifies as NGC 6141, 11 degrees from NGC 6363. Corwin: NGC 6138 = NGC 6363 (Stephan misidentified his comparison star; Esmiol's N6138 = N6263 is a misprint for N6363). NGC 6141 is the faint galaxy at 16 23 06.4 +40 51 30." +sources = [ + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/ngconly.txt", + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/ngcnotes.all", +] +same_as = "NGC 6363" +guard = false + +["IC 1028"] +why = "Steinicke makes IC 1028 a duplicate of NGC 5731, 62' away, so the import keeps it apart; his IC 1028 row is at NGC 5739's position. Corwin: IC 1028 = NGC 5739." +sources = [ + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/iconly.txt", + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/icnotes.all", +] +same_as = "NGC 5739" + +["IC 2145"] +why = "Steinicke lists IC 2145 and NGC 2086 as two objects 0.97' apart, so the import keeps two. Corwin: IC 2145 = NGC 2086, one nebula (N 160C); Bica et al. 2008 names them in one row, NGC2086,IC2145,LMC-N160C, 0.85'x0.80', the size NGC 2086 already has. Steinicke's 2.0' for IC 2145 goes with the duplicate." +sources = [ + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/iconly.txt", + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/icnotes.all", + "Bica et al. 2008, VizieR J/MNRAS/389/678 (astro_data/bica2008)", +] +same_as = "NGC 2086" + +["IC 4763"] +why = "Steinicke makes IC 4763 a duplicate of NGC 6677. Corwin, after reducing Bigourdan's micrometry: NGC 6677 is object A, and object B is NGC 6679 = IC 4763." +sources = [ + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/iconly.txt", + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/icnotes.all", +] +same_as = "NGC 6679" + +["NGC 6885"] +why = "NGC 6885 = NGC 6882 (Corwin, OpenNGC, Steinicke): one open cluster around 20 Vul. Steinicke's shared position is 5' north-west of Corwin's and OpenNGC's centre, 20 12 00 +26 30.2." +sources = [ + "http://haroldcorwin.net/ngcic/ngconly.txt", + "https://github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC/blob/master/database_files/NGC.csv", + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=NGC%206885", + "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caldwell_catalogue", +] +ra = "20 12 00" +dec = "+26 30 12" +was.ra = "20 11 40.60" +was.dec = "+26 32 54.0" diff --git a/astro_data/corrections/taas200.toml b/astro_data/corrections/taas200.toml new file mode 100644 index 000000000..649464953 --- /dev/null +++ b/astro_data/corrections/taas200.toml @@ -0,0 +1,8 @@ +# Corrections to the TAAS 200 list (TAAS_200.csv). +# See README.md in this directory for the format. +# was values from a build of 4da2a0a2b. + +["NGC 1502"] +why = "Catalog's only name 'Part of Kemble's Cascade' [Ta2] is a description (the cluster lies at the end of the Kemble's Cascade asterism), not a name." +sources = ["https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NGC_1502"] +names.remove = ["Part of Kemble's Cascade"] diff --git a/astro_data/corrections/tlk.toml b/astro_data/corrections/tlk.toml new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9ad88c542 --- /dev/null +++ b/astro_data/corrections/tlk.toml @@ -0,0 +1,80 @@ +# Corrections to the TLK 90 variable stars list (variables/). +# See README.md in this directory for the format. +# was values from a build of 4da2a0a2b. + +["TLK 76"] +why = "The position lies 3-30\" from its star, outside the cross-match's 3\" radius for an arcsecond position. Evidence: V 7 fits HIP 98909 8.22, no other star within 0.5' does." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2098909"] +hip = 98909 + +["TLK 15"] +why = "A variable whose catalog magnitude is not Hipparcos's V, so the cross-match's V gate turns its star away. Evidence: 0.5\" from HIP 31579; source's V is the error (V 7.83 vs HIP 31579 5.40)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2031579"] +hip = 31579 + +["TLK 16"] +why = "A variable whose catalog magnitude is not Hipparcos's V, so the cross-match's V gate turns its star away. Evidence: 0.4\" from HIP 17257; source's V is the error (V 11 vs HIP 17257 6.99)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2017257"] +hip = 17257 + +["TLK 17"] +why = "A variable whose catalog magnitude is not Hipparcos's V, so the cross-match's V gate turns its star away. Evidence: 0.5\" from HIP 22552; source's V is the error (V 9.2 vs HIP 22552 6.54)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2022552"] +hip = 22552 + +["TLK 19"] +why = "A variable whose catalog magnitude is not Hipparcos's V, so the cross-match's V gate turns its star away. Evidence: La Superba is HIP 62223; 0.3\" from HIP 62223; source's V is the error (V 7.4 vs HIP 62223 5.42). TLK gives La Superba (Y CVn) a range of 7.4-10.0, which is photographic. Its V range is 4.86-7.32 (GCVS)." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2062223", + "GCVS B/gcvs via VizieR (Y CVn SRB 4.86-7.32 V)", + "Bright Star Catalogue V/50 via VizieR HR 4846 V 4.99", + "SIMBAD (sim-tap, V and otype)", +] +hip = 62223 +mag = [4.86, 7.32] +was.mag = 5.42 + +["TLK 21"] +why = "A variable whose catalog magnitude is not Hipparcos's V, so the cross-match's V gate turns its star away. Evidence: 0.6\" from HIP 99990; source's V is the error (V 8.9 vs HIP 99990 6.97)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2099990"] +hip = 99990 + +["TLK 37"] +why = "A variable whose catalog magnitude is not Hipparcos's V, so the cross-match's V gate turns its star away. Evidence: 0.3\" from HIP 96836; source's V is the error (V 10.2 vs HIP 96836 7.63)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2096836"] +hip = 96836 + +["TLK 51"] +why = "A variable whose catalog magnitude is not Hipparcos's V, so the cross-match's V gate turns its star away. Evidence: 0.4\" from HIP 48327; source's V is the error (V 8.3 vs HIP 48327 6.85)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2048327"] +hip = 48327 + +["TLK 52"] +why = "A variable whose catalog magnitude is not Hipparcos's V, so the cross-match's V gate turns its star away. Evidence: 0.5\" from HIP 52009; source's V is the error (V 7 vs HIP 52009 4.89)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2052009"] +hip = 52009 + +["TLK 63"] +why = "A variable whose catalog magnitude is not Hipparcos's V, so the cross-match's V gate turns its star away. Evidence: 0.5\" from HIP 23680; source's V is the error (V 8.2 vs HIP 23680 6.10)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2023680"] +hip = 23680 + +["TLK 65"] +why = "A variable whose catalog magnitude is not Hipparcos's V, so the cross-match's V gate turns its star away. Evidence: 0.4\" from HIP 30564; source's V is the error (V 7.9 vs HIP 30564 6.30)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2030564"] +hip = 30564 + +["TLK 72"] +why = "A variable whose catalog magnitude is not Hipparcos's V, so the cross-match's V gate turns its star away. Evidence: 0.5\" from HIP 5914; source's V is the error (V 8.8 vs HIP 5914 6.76)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%205914"] +hip = 5914 + +["TLK 83"] +why = "A variable whose catalog magnitude is not Hipparcos's V, so the cross-match's V gate turns its star away. Evidence: 1.5\" from HIP 6759." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%206759"] +hip = 6759 + +["TLK 85"] +why = "A variable whose catalog magnitude is not Hipparcos's V, so the cross-match's V gate turns its star away. Evidence: 0.7\" from HIP 92442; source's V is the error (V 9.63 vs HIP 92442 6.82)." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2092442"] +hip = 92442 diff --git a/astro_data/corrections/wds.toml b/astro_data/corrections/wds.toml new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9f7e8c5c6 --- /dev/null +++ b/astro_data/corrections/wds.toml @@ -0,0 +1,26 @@ +# Corrections to the Washington Double Star Catalog (WDS). +# See README.md in this directory for the format. +# was values from a build of 4da2a0a2b. + +["WDS 24652"] +why = "A variable whose catalog magnitude is not Hipparcos's V, so the cross-match's V gate turns its star away. Evidence: 0.1\" from HIP 25673." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2025673"] +hip = 25673 + +["WDS 58296"] +why = "A variable whose catalog magnitude is not Hipparcos's V, so the cross-match's V gate turns its star away. Evidence: WDS DM ('+', 22, 2236) is HIP 51752's." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2051752"] +hip = 51752 + +["WDS 106086"] +why = "A variable whose catalog magnitude is not Hipparcos's V, so the cross-match's V gate turns its star away. Evidence: WDS DM ('+', 30, 3779) is HIP 97734's." +sources = ["https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2097734"] +hip = 97734 + +["WDS 99456"] +why = "WDS gives this pair's magnitudes in the K band (its note K: 'Summary line gives K-band or other infrared (>1 micron) magnitudes'), so the cross-match's V gate turns its star away: WDS's 4.94 is K, and HIP 94645's V is 6.25. Evidence: 1.4\" from SIMBAD's HD 179949 = HIP 94645 (Gumala, IAU WGSN)." +sources = [ + "https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=HIP%2094645", + "https://www.astro.gsu.edu/wds/Webtextfiles/wdsweb_format.txt", +] +hip = 94645 diff --git a/docs/adr/0046-catalog-corrections-cited-checked-applied-last.md b/docs/adr/0046-catalog-corrections-cited-checked-applied-last.md index e787d7207..89958fa7a 100644 --- a/docs/adr/0046-catalog-corrections-cited-checked-applied-last.md +++ b/docs/adr/0046-catalog-corrections-cited-checked-applied-last.md @@ -15,7 +15,7 @@ An audit of `objects.db` against OpenNGC and Hipparcos (paperChart_dev, 2026-10) 2. **A correction is keyed by a designator** (`"NGC 604"`) and applies to the sky object that designator resolves to; a description correction applies to that one catalog listing. `objects.id` is an autoincrement and changes on every rebuild, so it cannot be the key. Two corrections that reach the same field of one sky object through different designators (M 42, NGC 1976) fail the build, as does a designator that resolves to nothing. -3. **A correction does one of three things:** set fields (`obj_type`, `ra`, `dec`, `const`, `size`, `mag`, `description`); edit names (`names.add`, `names.remove`, and `names.preferred`, which puts a name first); or correct an **identification** — in either direction (`same_as = "IC 2480"`, or `own_object = true` to detach a designator into a sky object of its own), or, for a star listing, by naming its Hipparcos number (`hip = 102989`). It never creates a sky object from nothing or deletes a listing: every orphan and duplicate the audit found is a loader bug. +3. **A correction does one of three things:** set fields (`obj_type`, `ra`, `dec`, `const`, `size`, `mag`, `description`); edit names (`names.add`, `names.remove`, and `names.preferred`, which puts a name first); or correct an **identification** — in either direction (`same_as = "IC 2480"`, or `own_object = true` to detach a designator into a sky object of its own), or, for a star listing, by naming its Hipparcos number (`hip = 102989`). A field correction may also clear `mag` or `size` (`mag = ""`), for a sky object a split or a moved identification leaves holding another object's value. A `same_as` must pass the loaders' match guard (compatible types, and within 30′ or the target's major axis) from the listing's own position and type, unless it states `guard = false` for a cited identification whose source position is wrong; an `own_object` needs no guard, since its sky object starts at the old position. It never creates a sky object from nothing or deletes a listing: every orphan and duplicate the audit found is a loader bug. 4. **Corrections are applied in one final pass**, after every loader, the star cross-match, the supplementary sources and type normalisation, and before image resolution and the database is finalised. A correction therefore always has the last word, and its type is checked against the normalised type codes. A split (`own_object`) or a join (`same_as`) fails the build if the sky object it leaves still carries another catalog's name equal to the moved designator, since that catalog's listing was matched through the wrong identification and the move would leave it behind. @@ -23,7 +23,7 @@ An audit of `objects.db` against OpenNGC and Hipparcos (paperChart_dev, 2026-10) 5. **The format is TOML**: one table per designator, one file per corrected source, under `astro_data/corrections/` (`steinicke.toml`, `sac_multistars.toml`, `ngc2000_names.toml`…). Field names are the database's columns; values are in the units references publish — sexagesimal RA and Dec, sizes through the loaders' own `parse_arcmin_size`, a magnitude as a number or a variable's range as a list. `why` and `sources` (URLs) are required. -6. **Every field correction states the value it replaces** (`was.size = "120'"`), and the pass checks it, within tolerances (0.05 mag, 1″, sizes compared parsed). If the field already holds the corrected value, the correction is redundant; if it holds anything other than `was`, the correction is stale. Both fail the build. Name and identification operations carry the same check implicitly: a `names.remove` of an absent name, or a `same_as` on designators already one sky object, fails. +6. **Every field correction states the value it replaces** (`was.size = "120'"`), and the pass checks it, within tolerances (0.05 mag, 1″, sizes compared parsed). If the field already holds the corrected value, the correction is redundant; if it holds anything other than `was`, the correction is stale. Both fail the build. Name and identification operations carry the same check implicitly: a `names.remove` of an absent name, or a `same_as` on designators already one sky object, fails, as does a `guard = false` on a `same_as` the guard accepts. A size must parse to finite, positive extents. ## Considered options diff --git a/docs/ax/catalog.md b/docs/ax/catalog.md index cbe217124..2e4db4445 100644 --- a/docs/ax/catalog.md +++ b/docs/ax/catalog.md @@ -861,7 +861,8 @@ format, and every check, is documented in - **Keyed by designator**, applied to the sky object it resolves to; a description applies to that one listing. - **Three operations**: set fields (`obj_type`, `ra`, `dec`, `const`, - `size`, `mag`, `description`); edit names (`names.add`, + `size`, `mag`, `description`, and clear `size` or `mag` with `""`); + edit names (`names.add`, `names.remove`, `names.preferred`); correct an identification (`same_as`, `own_object`, or `hip` for a star listing — applied before the star cross-match, not in the final pass). @@ -872,7 +873,9 @@ format, and every check, is documented in one sky object, a designator that resolves to nothing, and a missing `why` or `sources`. Name and identification corrections are checked the same way: removing an absent name, or a `same_as` that is already - true, fails. + true, fails. A `same_as` must also pass the loaders' match guard from + the listing's own type and position, unless it opts out with a cited + `guard = false`; a size must be finite and positive. - **All or nothing.** Identifications go first, since they change what designators resolve to; every other correction is then checked before any is written, and a failure rolls the whole pass back. diff --git a/python/PiFinder/catalog_imports/catalog_import_utils.py b/python/PiFinder/catalog_imports/catalog_import_utils.py index 6c72ffd8d..381db68b3 100644 --- a/python/PiFinder/catalog_imports/catalog_import_utils.py +++ b/python/PiFinder/catalog_imports/catalog_import_utils.py @@ -548,7 +548,8 @@ def parse_arcmin_size(raw: str, strict: bool = False) -> SizeObject: SizeObject keeps the major axis first, so Collinder's "25x30" is 30' x 25'. Tokens whose numeric part can't be parsed (e.g. "nl", "see") are skipped with a warning, or raise ValueError when strict: a - correction's size is typed by hand and must parse whole. + correction's size is typed by hand and must parse whole, into finite, + positive extents ("nan", "inf" and "-5" parse as floats but are no size). """ if not raw: return SizeObject([]) @@ -560,6 +561,8 @@ def parse_arcmin_size(raw: str, strict: bool = False) -> SizeObject: arcsec = _size_token_to_arcsec(token) if arcsec is None and strict: raise ValueError(f"non-numeric size token {token!r} in {raw!r}") + if strict and arcsec is not None and not (math.isfinite(arcsec) and arcsec > 0): + raise ValueError(f"size token {token!r} in {raw!r} is not a positive size") if arcsec is None: logging.warning("Non-numeric size token %r in %r", token, raw) else: diff --git a/python/PiFinder/catalog_imports/corrections.py b/python/PiFinder/catalog_imports/corrections.py index 0b2008558..86faa8f8e 100644 --- a/python/PiFinder/catalog_imports/corrections.py +++ b/python/PiFinder/catalog_imports/corrections.py @@ -34,6 +34,7 @@ from PiFinder.obj_types import OBJ_TYPES from .catalog_import_utils import ( listing_named, + match_guard, merge_sky_object, move_names, object_names, @@ -60,7 +61,17 @@ SIZE_TOLERANCE_ARCSEC = 1.0 _FLOAT_SLACK = 1e-9 -_KEYS = {"why", "sources", "was", "names", "same_as", "own_object", "hip", *FIELDS} +_KEYS = { + "why", + "sources", + "was", + "names", + "same_as", + "guard", + "own_object", + "hip", + *FIELDS, +} _NAME_KEYS = {"add", "remove", "preferred"} # A catalog code, one space, and a number without leading zeros: "NGC 604", @@ -98,6 +109,9 @@ class Correction: names_remove: List[str] = field(default_factory=list) names_preferred: Optional[str] = None same_as: Optional[Tuple[str, int]] = None + # False opts a same_as out of the match guard, for a cited identification + # whose listing's source position or type is wrong. + guard: bool = True own_object: bool = False hip: Optional[int] = None @@ -228,6 +242,17 @@ def _parse_description(value: Any) -> str: "description": str, } +# Fields a correction can clear, with `size = ""`: where a split or a moved +# identification leaves a sky object holding another object's value, and no +# source gives its own. +_CLEARABLE = ("size", "mag") + + +def _parse_value(field_name: str, value: Any) -> Any: + if value == "" and field_name in _CLEARABLE: + return _EMPTY[field_name]() + return _FIELD_PARSERS[field_name](value) + def _parse_was(field_name: str, value: Any) -> Any: if value == "" and field_name in _EMPTY: @@ -365,8 +390,8 @@ def problem(message: str) -> None: for field_name in FIELDS: if field_name in table: try: - correction.fields[field_name] = _FIELD_PARSERS[field_name]( - table[field_name] + correction.fields[field_name] = _parse_value( + field_name, table[field_name] ) except ValueError as error: problem(str(error)) @@ -459,6 +484,13 @@ def _parse_identification( else: if correction.same_as == correction.listing: problem("same_as names the designator itself") + if "guard" in table: + if table["guard"] is not False: + problem("guard can only be false") + elif "same_as" not in table: + problem("guard = false without a same_as") + else: + correction.guard = False if "own_object" in table: if table["own_object"] is not True: problem("own_object can only be true") @@ -521,12 +553,13 @@ def apply_corrections(db: ObjectsDatabase, corrections: List[Correction]) -> Non def _apply(cursor: sqlite3.Cursor, corrections: List[Correction]) -> None: - moved = _apply_identifications(cursor, corrections) + moved, joined_from = _apply_identifications(cursor, corrections) planned = _plan(cursor, corrections) for correction, listing_id, object_id in planned: _write(cursor, correction, listing_id, object_id) _recompute_constellations(cursor, planned) _check_nothing_left_behind(cursor, moved) + _check_match_guard(cursor, joined_from) logging.info( "Applied %d corrections (hip identifications are left to the star" " cross-match: %d)", @@ -618,8 +651,12 @@ def _move_listing( def _apply_identifications( cursor: sqlite3.Cursor, corrections: List[Correction] -) -> List[Tuple[Correction, int]]: - """Apply own_object and same_as; return each with the sky object it left.""" +) -> Tuple[List[Tuple[Correction, int]], List[Tuple[Correction, sqlite3.Row]]]: + """Apply own_object and same_as. + + Returns each with the sky object it left, and each same_as with that sky + object's type and position, as the listing's own for the match guard. + """ identifications = [c for c in corrections if c.own_object or c.same_as] problems: List[str] = [] claimed: Dict[Tuple[str, int], Correction] = {} @@ -642,6 +679,7 @@ def _apply_identifications( raise CorrectionError(problems) moved: List[Tuple[Correction, int]] = [] + joined_from: List[Tuple[Correction, sqlite3.Row]] = [] splits_first = sorted(identifications, key=lambda c: not c.own_object) for correction in splits_first: listing, why_not = resolve_listing(cursor, correction.listing) @@ -680,6 +718,15 @@ def _apply_identifications( " already the same sky object" ) continue + joined_from.append( + ( + correction, + cursor.execute( + "SELECT obj_type, ra, dec FROM objects WHERE id = ?", + (source,), + ).fetchone(), + ) + ) if siblings: _move_listing( cursor, correction, listing["id"], source, target["object_id"] @@ -690,7 +737,7 @@ def _apply_identifications( moved.append((correction, source)) if problems: raise CorrectionError(problems) - return moved + return moved, joined_from def _plan( @@ -914,3 +961,40 @@ def _check_nothing_left_behind( ) if problems: raise CorrectionError(problems) + + +def _check_match_guard( + cursor: sqlite3.Cursor, joined_from: List[Tuple[Correction, sqlite3.Row]] +) -> None: + """Fail a same_as that the loaders' match guard would reject. + + The listing's own type and position, those of the sky object it left, + must be compatible with the sky object it joined, as corrected, and lie + within the match radius or that sky object's major axis. `guard = false` + opts out a cited identification whose source position or type is wrong; + on a same_as the guard accepts, it is redundant and fails too. + """ + problems = [] + for correction, origin in joined_from: + listing, _why_not = resolve_listing(cursor, correction.listing) + assert listing is not None + target = cursor.execute( + "SELECT obj_type, ra, dec, size FROM objects WHERE id = ?", + (listing["object_id"],), + ).fetchone() + reason = match_guard(origin["obj_type"], origin["ra"], origin["dec"], target) + target_designator = _designator(cast(Tuple[str, int], correction.same_as)) + if reason and correction.guard: + problems.append( + f"{correction.label}: same_as {target_designator}: the match guard" + f" rejects it ({reason}); if the identification is right and the" + " source's position or type is wrong, say so in `why` and add" + " guard = false" + ) + elif not reason and not correction.guard: + problems.append( + f"{correction.label}: guard = false, but the match guard accepts" + f" same_as {target_designator}; delete it" + ) + if problems: + raise CorrectionError(problems) diff --git a/python/tests/test_catalog_corrections.py b/python/tests/test_catalog_corrections.py index 0f7c7f2f9..ea0d9d529 100644 --- a/python/tests/test_catalog_corrections.py +++ b/python/tests/test_catalog_corrections.py @@ -87,6 +87,18 @@ def db(tmp_path): [("SaM", 1297, "alpha Mic")], [("SaM 1297", "SaM")], ), + # M 43, 7.5' from M 42 + ( + ("Nb", 83.879, -5.2675, "Ori", _size(1200, 900), _mag(9.0)), + [("NGC", 1982, "B, L, R")], + [("NGC 1982", "NGC")], + ), + # 1.5' from NGC 7466 + ( + ("Gx", 345.53, 27.04, "Peg", _size(30), _mag(15.0)), + [("IC", 5283, "eF, S")], + [("IC 5283", "IC")], + ), ] for values, listings, names in objects: object_id = db.insert_object(*values) @@ -258,13 +270,25 @@ def test_load_parses_values_into_reference_units(corrections_dir): (CITED + 'const = "Orion"\nwas.const = "Ori"', "not an IAU constellation"), (CITED + 'size = "2.5\' x see"\nwas.size = ""', "non-numeric size token"), (CITED + 'size = 2.5\nwas.size = ""', "size must be a string"), + (CITED + 'size = "nan"\nwas.size = ""', "is not a positive size"), + (CITED + 'size = "inf"\nwas.size = ""', "is not a positive size"), + (CITED + 'size = "-5"\nwas.size = ""', "is not a positive size"), + (CITED + 'size = "0\'"\nwas.size = ""', "is not a positive size"), + (CITED + 'size = "3\'x-1\'"\nwas.size = ""', "is not a positive size"), + (CITED + 'size = "2\'"\nwas.size = "nan"', "was.size: size token"), (CITED + 'mag = "11.4"\nwas.mag = ""', "mag must be a number"), (CITED + 'mag = true\nwas.mag = ""', "mag must be a number"), (CITED + 'ra = 83.4\nwas.ra = "05 33 37"', "sexagesimal string"), (CITED + 'size = "2.5\'"\nwas.size = "150\\""', "corrects nothing"), (CITED + "mag = 4.0\nwas.mag = 4.04", "corrects nothing"), + (CITED + 'mag = ""\nwas.mag = ""', "corrects nothing"), + (CITED + 'obj_type = ""\nwas.obj_type = "Nb"', "not a type code"), + (CITED + 'description = ""\nwas.description = "F"', "non-empty string"), (CITED + 'same_as = "IC 2480"\nown_object = true', "contradict"), (CITED + "own_object = false", "can only be true"), + (CITED + 'same_as = "IC 2480"\nguard = true', "guard can only be false"), + (CITED + 'same_as = "IC 2480"\nguard = "no"', "guard can only be false"), + (CITED + "own_object = true\nguard = false", "without a same_as"), (CITED + 'same_as = "IC 424"', "the designator itself"), (CITED + 'same_as = "IC424"', "same_as: 'IC424' is not a designator"), (CITED + "names.add = []", "names.add must be a non-empty list"), @@ -393,6 +417,27 @@ def test_mag_takes_a_number_or_a_range(db, corrections_dir): assert mag["filter_mag"] == pytest.approx(4.86) +def test_a_magnitude_and_a_size_can_be_cleared(db, corrections_dir): + apply( + db, + corrections_dir, + '["M 82"]\n' + CITED + 'mag = ""\nwas.mag = 8.4\n' + 'size = ""\nwas.size = "11.2\'x4.3\'"\n', + ) + assert json.loads(sky_object(db, "M", 82)["mag"]) == { + "mags": [], + "filter_mag": 99, + } + assert json.loads(sky_object(db, "M", 82)["size"])["e"] == [] + + +def test_clearing_an_empty_field_is_redundant(db, corrections_dir): + problems = apply_fails( + db, corrections_dir, '["IC 424"]\n' + CITED + 'mag = ""\nwas.mag = 4.0\n' + ) + assert 'mag is already ""; the correction is redundant' in problems + + def test_a_field_correction_reaches_the_sky_object_through_any_designator( db, corrections_dir ): @@ -622,9 +667,9 @@ def test_same_as_merges_a_lone_listing_into_the_other_sky_object(db, corrections def test_same_as_moves_one_listing_off_a_shared_sky_object(db, corrections_dir): - apply(db, corrections_dir, '["IC 5281"]\n' + CITED + 'same_as = "IC 2480"\n') - assert object_id(db, "IC", 5281) == object_id(db, "IC", 2480) - assert names(db, "IC", 5281) == ["IC 2480", "IC 5281"] + apply(db, corrections_dir, '["IC 5281"]\n' + CITED + 'same_as = "IC 5283"\n') + assert object_id(db, "IC", 5281) == object_id(db, "IC", 5283) + assert names(db, "IC", 5281) == ["IC 5283", "IC 5281"] assert names(db, "NGC", 7466) == ["NGC 7466"] @@ -704,14 +749,14 @@ def test_same_as_a_split_designator_joins_its_new_sky_object(db, corrections_dir apply( db, corrections_dir, - '["IC 2477"]\n' + '["IC 5283"]\n' + CITED + 'same_as = "IC 5281"\n' + '["IC 5281"]\n' + CITED + "own_object = true\n", ) - assert object_id(db, "IC", 2477) == object_id(db, "IC", 5281) + assert object_id(db, "IC", 5283) == object_id(db, "IC", 5281) assert object_id(db, "IC", 5281) != object_id(db, "NGC", 7466) @@ -753,7 +798,9 @@ def test_a_stray_name_left_behind_can_be_removed_by_a_correction(db, corrections assert names(db, "IC", 5281) == ["IC 5281"] -@pytest.mark.parametrize("identification", ["own_object = true", 'same_as = "IC 2480"']) +@pytest.mark.parametrize( + "identification", ["own_object = true", 'same_as = "NGC 1982"'] +) def test_moving_an_m_listing_needs_the_ngc_records_m_name_removed( db, corrections_dir, identification ): @@ -853,3 +900,57 @@ def test_a_failed_check_rolls_back_the_identifications_too(db, corrections_dir): + "mag = 4.1\nwas.mag = 9.0\n", ) assert object_id(db, "IC", 2477) != object_id(db, "IC", 2480) + + +def test_same_as_far_from_the_listing_fails_the_match_guard(db, corrections_dir): + problems = apply_fails( + db, corrections_dir, '["IC 5281"]\n' + CITED + 'same_as = "IC 2480"\n' + ) + assert "[IC 5281]: same_as IC 2480: the match guard rejects it (" in problems + assert "apart, limit 30'" in problems + assert object_id(db, "IC", 5281) == object_id(db, "NGC", 7466) # rolled back + + +def test_same_as_of_an_incompatible_type_fails_the_match_guard(db, corrections_dir): + star = db.insert_object("*", 345.515, 27.054, "Peg", _size(), _mag(9.5)) + db.insert_catalog_object(star, "SaM", 2000, "a star by NGC 7466") + db.insert_name(star, "SaM 2000", "SaM") + problems = apply_fails( + db, corrections_dir, '["SaM 2000"]\n' + CITED + 'same_as = "NGC 7466"\n' + ) + assert "the match guard rejects it (types * and Gx)" in problems + + +def test_guard_false_lets_a_cited_far_identification_through(db, corrections_dir): + apply( + db, + corrections_dir, + '["IC 5281"]\n' + CITED + 'same_as = "IC 2480"\nguard = false\n', + ) + assert object_id(db, "IC", 5281) == object_id(db, "IC", 2480) + + +def test_guard_false_on_a_same_as_the_guard_accepts_is_redundant(db, corrections_dir): + problems = apply_fails( + db, + corrections_dir, + '["IC 5283"]\n' + CITED + 'same_as = "NGC 7466"\nguard = false\n', + ) + assert "guard = false, but the match guard accepts same_as NGC 7466" in problems + + +def test_the_match_guard_sees_the_target_as_corrected(db, corrections_dir): + # As for Lyn 855 and Col 401: the target's own position is wrong, and a + # correction in the same pass moves it next to the listing. + apply( + db, + corrections_dir, + '["IC 5283"]\n' + + CITED + + 'same_as = "IC 2480"\n' + + '["IC 2480"]\n' + + CITED + + 'ra = "23 02 07"\nwas.ra = "08 00 24"\n' + + 'dec = "+27 02 24"\nwas.dec = "-40 06 00"\n', + ) + assert object_id(db, "IC", 5283) == object_id(db, "IC", 2480)